Understanding Public Responses to Emerging Technologies: A Narrative Approach

Philip Macnaghten, S.R. Davies, Matthew Kearnes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Previous studies aimed at understanding public responses to emerging technologies have given limited attention to the social and cultural processes through which public concerns emerge. When probed, these have tended to be explained either in cognitive social psychological terms, typically in the form of cognitive shortcuts or heuristics or the influence of affective variables, or in social interactionist terms, as a product of the micro dynamics of the social interaction. We argue for an alternative approach that examines how public attitudes are formed in relation to the interplay of wider cultural narratives about science and technology. Using data from recent qualitative research with publics on nanotechnology and other emerging technologies, we develop a typology of five cultural narratives that underpin and structure public talk. The narratives we identify within focus group talk are familiar stories that are deeply embedded in contemporary culture, and which provide cultural resources for navigating the issues posed by emerging technology. Substantively, they inform a ‘tragic’ mood on the prospects of emerging technology, reflecting the loss of belief in science, when coupled to neo-liberal logics, as guaranteeing social progress. The implications for policy-making are discussed.

LanguageEnglish
Pages504-518
JournalJournal of Environmental Policy and Planning
Volume21
Issue number5
Early online date10 Jun 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

public attitude
nanotechnology
heuristics
science and technology
policy making
typology
public
resource
loss
science
product

Cite this

@article{c011b79e316d4105898a71c07255472f,
title = "Understanding Public Responses to Emerging Technologies: A Narrative Approach",
abstract = "Previous studies aimed at understanding public responses to emerging technologies have given limited attention to the social and cultural processes through which public concerns emerge. When probed, these have tended to be explained either in cognitive social psychological terms, typically in the form of cognitive shortcuts or heuristics or the influence of affective variables, or in social interactionist terms, as a product of the micro dynamics of the social interaction. We argue for an alternative approach that examines how public attitudes are formed in relation to the interplay of wider cultural narratives about science and technology. Using data from recent qualitative research with publics on nanotechnology and other emerging technologies, we develop a typology of five cultural narratives that underpin and structure public talk. The narratives we identify within focus group talk are familiar stories that are deeply embedded in contemporary culture, and which provide cultural resources for navigating the issues posed by emerging technology. Substantively, they inform a ‘tragic’ mood on the prospects of emerging technology, reflecting the loss of belief in science, when coupled to neo-liberal logics, as guaranteeing social progress. The implications for policy-making are discussed.",
author = "Philip Macnaghten and S.R. Davies and Matthew Kearnes",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1080/1523908X.2015.1053110",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "504--518",
journal = "Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning",
issn = "1523-908X",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "5",

}

Understanding Public Responses to Emerging Technologies: A Narrative Approach. / Macnaghten, Philip; Davies, S.R.; Kearnes, Matthew.

In: Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, Vol. 21, No. 5, 2019, p. 504-518.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Understanding Public Responses to Emerging Technologies: A Narrative Approach

AU - Macnaghten, Philip

AU - Davies, S.R.

AU - Kearnes, Matthew

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Previous studies aimed at understanding public responses to emerging technologies have given limited attention to the social and cultural processes through which public concerns emerge. When probed, these have tended to be explained either in cognitive social psychological terms, typically in the form of cognitive shortcuts or heuristics or the influence of affective variables, or in social interactionist terms, as a product of the micro dynamics of the social interaction. We argue for an alternative approach that examines how public attitudes are formed in relation to the interplay of wider cultural narratives about science and technology. Using data from recent qualitative research with publics on nanotechnology and other emerging technologies, we develop a typology of five cultural narratives that underpin and structure public talk. The narratives we identify within focus group talk are familiar stories that are deeply embedded in contemporary culture, and which provide cultural resources for navigating the issues posed by emerging technology. Substantively, they inform a ‘tragic’ mood on the prospects of emerging technology, reflecting the loss of belief in science, when coupled to neo-liberal logics, as guaranteeing social progress. The implications for policy-making are discussed.

AB - Previous studies aimed at understanding public responses to emerging technologies have given limited attention to the social and cultural processes through which public concerns emerge. When probed, these have tended to be explained either in cognitive social psychological terms, typically in the form of cognitive shortcuts or heuristics or the influence of affective variables, or in social interactionist terms, as a product of the micro dynamics of the social interaction. We argue for an alternative approach that examines how public attitudes are formed in relation to the interplay of wider cultural narratives about science and technology. Using data from recent qualitative research with publics on nanotechnology and other emerging technologies, we develop a typology of five cultural narratives that underpin and structure public talk. The narratives we identify within focus group talk are familiar stories that are deeply embedded in contemporary culture, and which provide cultural resources for navigating the issues posed by emerging technology. Substantively, they inform a ‘tragic’ mood on the prospects of emerging technology, reflecting the loss of belief in science, when coupled to neo-liberal logics, as guaranteeing social progress. The implications for policy-making are discussed.

U2 - 10.1080/1523908X.2015.1053110

DO - 10.1080/1523908X.2015.1053110

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 504

EP - 518

JO - Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning

T2 - Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning

JF - Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning

SN - 1523-908X

IS - 5

ER -