Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf

T. Vihma, T. Kilpeläinen, L. Rontu, P.S. Anderson, A. Orr, T. Phillips, K. Finkele, I. Rodrigo, A.A.M. Holtslag, G. Svensson

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference paperAcademic

Abstract

Numerical weather prediction and climate models continue to have large errors for stable boundary layers (SBL). To understand and to improve on this, so far three atmospheric boundary layer model inter-comparison studies have been organised within the Global Energy and Water Cycle Experiment (GEWEX) of the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP). The previous GEWEX ABL Studies (GABLS) have joined about 20 research groups to model the SBL (GABLS1), the diurnal cycle (GABLS2, GABLS3) and the nocturnal low-level jet (GABLS3). With GABLS4 we aim to increase the further understanding of performance and challenges of numerical models in very stable conditions and contribute to the development of parameterization schemes. In this study we explore the set-up of GABLS4 over the Brunt Ice Shelf, Antarctica, where the British Antarctic Survey carries out measurements at the Halley station, including flux and profile measurements from a 32-m-high instrumented mast as well as tethersonde and rawinsonde soundings. The preparatory work towards GABLS4 includes mesoscale model experiments for selected periods (pre-GABLS4). One of these periods is May 2003, when a very stable boundary layer developed at Halley. On 18th of May, the 1-m wind speed calmed down to less than 1 m/s, the 1-m air temperature dropped to -35°C, and a 15°C inversion was generated in the 31 m layer observed by the mast instruments. The observed air temperature and wind included many oscillations with typical periods of 0.5 to 2 h which introduce further challenges. The 18th of May case was simulated applying four mesoscale models: The Polar WRF, HIRLAM, AROME, and the Unified Model (UM). All models took the initial and boundary conditions from ECMWF analyses and applied two or three nested domains, with a 2.5 to 4 km horizontal resolution in the finest domain covering the Brunt Ice Shelf, mostly ice-covered ocean, and parts of the sloping ice sheet. The vertical resolution and physical parameterization schemes for ABL turbulence, radiation, clouds, and heat conduction in the snow varied between the models. The model results were validated against the observations paying attention, among others, to the decoupling of the snow surface and the SBL, and the surface energy balance terms. The modelling challenges include the heat conduction in the snow and the decrease of the downward sensible heat flux with increasing air-surface temperature difference. The pre-GABLS4 mesoscale experiments provided information that is essential for the selection of the GABLS4 case, to be addressed by single column (SCM) and LES models. The pressure gradient was weak during the study period, with mostly ageostrophic winds at Halley. Also the lateral heat advection was weak, and the mesoscale model results can probably be applied to prescribe it for the SCM experiments. The conditions favour the set-up for a GABLS4 inter-comparison case for SCM's but this needs further discussion.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA)
Place of PublicationBoston
PublisherAmerican Meteorological Society
Pages3B.1
Publication statusPublished - 2012
Event20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction - Boston, United States
Duration: 9 Jul 201213 Jul 2012

Conference

Conference20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction
CountryUnited States
CityBoston
Period9/07/1213/07/12

Fingerprint

ice shelf
boundary layer
energy
experiment
water
air temperature
snow
parameterization
sensible heat flux
surface energy
pressure gradient
research program
energy balance
ice sheet
climate modeling
advection
surface temperature
boundary condition
wind velocity
turbulence

Cite this

Vihma, T., Kilpeläinen, T., Rontu, L., Anderson, P. S., Orr, A., Phillips, T., ... Svensson, G. (2012). Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf. In 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA) (pp. 3B.1). Boston: American Meteorological Society.
Vihma, T. ; Kilpeläinen, T. ; Rontu, L. ; Anderson, P.S. ; Orr, A. ; Phillips, T. ; Finkele, K. ; Rodrigo, I. ; Holtslag, A.A.M. ; Svensson, G. / Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf. 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA). Boston : American Meteorological Society, 2012. pp. 3B.1
@inproceedings{de1b1ed16b154ab78c5ba835c58694a2,
title = "Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf",
abstract = "Numerical weather prediction and climate models continue to have large errors for stable boundary layers (SBL). To understand and to improve on this, so far three atmospheric boundary layer model inter-comparison studies have been organised within the Global Energy and Water Cycle Experiment (GEWEX) of the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP). The previous GEWEX ABL Studies (GABLS) have joined about 20 research groups to model the SBL (GABLS1), the diurnal cycle (GABLS2, GABLS3) and the nocturnal low-level jet (GABLS3). With GABLS4 we aim to increase the further understanding of performance and challenges of numerical models in very stable conditions and contribute to the development of parameterization schemes. In this study we explore the set-up of GABLS4 over the Brunt Ice Shelf, Antarctica, where the British Antarctic Survey carries out measurements at the Halley station, including flux and profile measurements from a 32-m-high instrumented mast as well as tethersonde and rawinsonde soundings. The preparatory work towards GABLS4 includes mesoscale model experiments for selected periods (pre-GABLS4). One of these periods is May 2003, when a very stable boundary layer developed at Halley. On 18th of May, the 1-m wind speed calmed down to less than 1 m/s, the 1-m air temperature dropped to -35°C, and a 15°C inversion was generated in the 31 m layer observed by the mast instruments. The observed air temperature and wind included many oscillations with typical periods of 0.5 to 2 h which introduce further challenges. The 18th of May case was simulated applying four mesoscale models: The Polar WRF, HIRLAM, AROME, and the Unified Model (UM). All models took the initial and boundary conditions from ECMWF analyses and applied two or three nested domains, with a 2.5 to 4 km horizontal resolution in the finest domain covering the Brunt Ice Shelf, mostly ice-covered ocean, and parts of the sloping ice sheet. The vertical resolution and physical parameterization schemes for ABL turbulence, radiation, clouds, and heat conduction in the snow varied between the models. The model results were validated against the observations paying attention, among others, to the decoupling of the snow surface and the SBL, and the surface energy balance terms. The modelling challenges include the heat conduction in the snow and the decrease of the downward sensible heat flux with increasing air-surface temperature difference. The pre-GABLS4 mesoscale experiments provided information that is essential for the selection of the GABLS4 case, to be addressed by single column (SCM) and LES models. The pressure gradient was weak during the study period, with mostly ageostrophic winds at Halley. Also the lateral heat advection was weak, and the mesoscale model results can probably be applied to prescribe it for the SCM experiments. The conditions favour the set-up for a GABLS4 inter-comparison case for SCM's but this needs further discussion.",
author = "T. Vihma and T. Kilpel{\"a}inen and L. Rontu and P.S. Anderson and A. Orr and T. Phillips and K. Finkele and I. Rodrigo and A.A.M. Holtslag and G. Svensson",
note = "recorded presentation: https://ams.confex.com/ams/20BLT18AirSea/flvgateway.cgi/id/21880?recordingid=21880",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
pages = "3B.1",
booktitle = "20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA)",
publisher = "American Meteorological Society",
address = "United States",

}

Vihma, T, Kilpeläinen, T, Rontu, L, Anderson, PS, Orr, A, Phillips, T, Finkele, K, Rodrigo, I, Holtslag, AAM & Svensson, G 2012, Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf. in 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA). American Meteorological Society, Boston, pp. 3B.1, 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, Boston, United States, 9/07/12.

Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf. / Vihma, T.; Kilpeläinen, T.; Rontu, L.; Anderson, P.S.; Orr, A.; Phillips, T.; Finkele, K.; Rodrigo, I.; Holtslag, A.A.M.; Svensson, G.

20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA). Boston : American Meteorological Society, 2012. p. 3B.1.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference paperAcademic

TY - GEN

T1 - Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf

AU - Vihma, T.

AU - Kilpeläinen, T.

AU - Rontu, L.

AU - Anderson, P.S.

AU - Orr, A.

AU - Phillips, T.

AU - Finkele, K.

AU - Rodrigo, I.

AU - Holtslag, A.A.M.

AU - Svensson, G.

N1 - recorded presentation: https://ams.confex.com/ams/20BLT18AirSea/flvgateway.cgi/id/21880?recordingid=21880

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - Numerical weather prediction and climate models continue to have large errors for stable boundary layers (SBL). To understand and to improve on this, so far three atmospheric boundary layer model inter-comparison studies have been organised within the Global Energy and Water Cycle Experiment (GEWEX) of the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP). The previous GEWEX ABL Studies (GABLS) have joined about 20 research groups to model the SBL (GABLS1), the diurnal cycle (GABLS2, GABLS3) and the nocturnal low-level jet (GABLS3). With GABLS4 we aim to increase the further understanding of performance and challenges of numerical models in very stable conditions and contribute to the development of parameterization schemes. In this study we explore the set-up of GABLS4 over the Brunt Ice Shelf, Antarctica, where the British Antarctic Survey carries out measurements at the Halley station, including flux and profile measurements from a 32-m-high instrumented mast as well as tethersonde and rawinsonde soundings. The preparatory work towards GABLS4 includes mesoscale model experiments for selected periods (pre-GABLS4). One of these periods is May 2003, when a very stable boundary layer developed at Halley. On 18th of May, the 1-m wind speed calmed down to less than 1 m/s, the 1-m air temperature dropped to -35°C, and a 15°C inversion was generated in the 31 m layer observed by the mast instruments. The observed air temperature and wind included many oscillations with typical periods of 0.5 to 2 h which introduce further challenges. The 18th of May case was simulated applying four mesoscale models: The Polar WRF, HIRLAM, AROME, and the Unified Model (UM). All models took the initial and boundary conditions from ECMWF analyses and applied two or three nested domains, with a 2.5 to 4 km horizontal resolution in the finest domain covering the Brunt Ice Shelf, mostly ice-covered ocean, and parts of the sloping ice sheet. The vertical resolution and physical parameterization schemes for ABL turbulence, radiation, clouds, and heat conduction in the snow varied between the models. The model results were validated against the observations paying attention, among others, to the decoupling of the snow surface and the SBL, and the surface energy balance terms. The modelling challenges include the heat conduction in the snow and the decrease of the downward sensible heat flux with increasing air-surface temperature difference. The pre-GABLS4 mesoscale experiments provided information that is essential for the selection of the GABLS4 case, to be addressed by single column (SCM) and LES models. The pressure gradient was weak during the study period, with mostly ageostrophic winds at Halley. Also the lateral heat advection was weak, and the mesoscale model results can probably be applied to prescribe it for the SCM experiments. The conditions favour the set-up for a GABLS4 inter-comparison case for SCM's but this needs further discussion.

AB - Numerical weather prediction and climate models continue to have large errors for stable boundary layers (SBL). To understand and to improve on this, so far three atmospheric boundary layer model inter-comparison studies have been organised within the Global Energy and Water Cycle Experiment (GEWEX) of the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP). The previous GEWEX ABL Studies (GABLS) have joined about 20 research groups to model the SBL (GABLS1), the diurnal cycle (GABLS2, GABLS3) and the nocturnal low-level jet (GABLS3). With GABLS4 we aim to increase the further understanding of performance and challenges of numerical models in very stable conditions and contribute to the development of parameterization schemes. In this study we explore the set-up of GABLS4 over the Brunt Ice Shelf, Antarctica, where the British Antarctic Survey carries out measurements at the Halley station, including flux and profile measurements from a 32-m-high instrumented mast as well as tethersonde and rawinsonde soundings. The preparatory work towards GABLS4 includes mesoscale model experiments for selected periods (pre-GABLS4). One of these periods is May 2003, when a very stable boundary layer developed at Halley. On 18th of May, the 1-m wind speed calmed down to less than 1 m/s, the 1-m air temperature dropped to -35°C, and a 15°C inversion was generated in the 31 m layer observed by the mast instruments. The observed air temperature and wind included many oscillations with typical periods of 0.5 to 2 h which introduce further challenges. The 18th of May case was simulated applying four mesoscale models: The Polar WRF, HIRLAM, AROME, and the Unified Model (UM). All models took the initial and boundary conditions from ECMWF analyses and applied two or three nested domains, with a 2.5 to 4 km horizontal resolution in the finest domain covering the Brunt Ice Shelf, mostly ice-covered ocean, and parts of the sloping ice sheet. The vertical resolution and physical parameterization schemes for ABL turbulence, radiation, clouds, and heat conduction in the snow varied between the models. The model results were validated against the observations paying attention, among others, to the decoupling of the snow surface and the SBL, and the surface energy balance terms. The modelling challenges include the heat conduction in the snow and the decrease of the downward sensible heat flux with increasing air-surface temperature difference. The pre-GABLS4 mesoscale experiments provided information that is essential for the selection of the GABLS4 case, to be addressed by single column (SCM) and LES models. The pressure gradient was weak during the study period, with mostly ageostrophic winds at Halley. Also the lateral heat advection was weak, and the mesoscale model results can probably be applied to prescribe it for the SCM experiments. The conditions favour the set-up for a GABLS4 inter-comparison case for SCM's but this needs further discussion.

M3 - Conference paper

SP - 3B.1

BT - 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA)

PB - American Meteorological Society

CY - Boston

ER -

Vihma T, Kilpeläinen T, Rontu L, Anderson PS, Orr A, Phillips T et al. Towards the fourth GEWEX atmospheric boundary layer model intercomparison study (GABLS4): exploration of very stable conditions over an Antarctic ice shelf. In 20th Symposium on Boundary Layers and Turbulence/18th Conference on Air-Sea Interaction, American Meteorological Society (9-13 July 2012, Boston, MA). Boston: American Meteorological Society. 2012. p. 3B.1