Towards a functional basis for predicting vegetation patterns; incorporating plant traits in habitat distribution models

Jacob C. Douma, Jan Philip M. Witte, Rien Aerts, Ruud P. Bartholomeus, Jenny C. Ordoñez, Harry Olde Venterink, Martin J. Wassen, Peter M. van Bodegom

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Reliably predicting vegetation distribution requires habitat distribution models (HDMs) that are ecologically sound. Current correlative HDMs are increasingly criticized because they lack sufficient functional basis. To include functional information into these models, we integrated two concepts from community ecology into a new type of HDM. We incorporated: 1) species selection by their traits in which only those species that pass the environmental filter can be part of the community (assembly theory); 2) that the occurrence probability of a community is determined by the extent to which the community mean traits fit the required traits as set by the environment. In this paper, our trait-based HDM is presented and its predictive capacity explored. Our approach consists of two steps. In step 1, four plant traits (stem-specific density and indicator values for nutrients, moisture and acidity) are predicted from four dominant environmental drivers (disturbance, nutrient supply, moisture supply and acidity) using regression. In step 2, these traits are used to predict the occurrence probability of 13 vegetation types, covering the majority of vegetation types across the Netherlands. The model was validated by comparison to the observed vegetation type for 263 plots in the Netherlands. Model performance was within the range of conventional HDMs and decreased with increasing uncertainty in the environment-trait relationships and with an increasing number of vegetation types. This study shows that including functionality into HDMs is not necessarily at the cost of model performance, while it has several conceptual advantages among including an increased insight in the functional characteristics of the vegetation and sources of unpredictability in community assembly. As such it is a promising first step towards more functional HDMs. Further development of a trait-based HDM hinges on replacing indicator values by truly functional traits and the translation of these relationships into mechanistic relationships.

LanguageEnglish
Pages294-305
JournalEcography
Volume35
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

vegetation
habitat
habitats
vegetation types
vegetation type
acidity
distribution
Netherlands
moisture
environmental disturbance
community ecology
nutrient
functional properties
uncertainty
nutritive value
stem
filter
stems
nutrients

Cite this

Douma, Jacob C. ; Witte, Jan Philip M. ; Aerts, Rien ; Bartholomeus, Ruud P. ; Ordoñez, Jenny C. ; Venterink, Harry Olde ; Wassen, Martin J. ; van Bodegom, Peter M. / Towards a functional basis for predicting vegetation patterns; incorporating plant traits in habitat distribution models. In: Ecography. 2012 ; Vol. 35, No. 4. pp. 294-305.
@article{42e03d945754454996c1f6364807bfd8,
title = "Towards a functional basis for predicting vegetation patterns; incorporating plant traits in habitat distribution models",
abstract = "Reliably predicting vegetation distribution requires habitat distribution models (HDMs) that are ecologically sound. Current correlative HDMs are increasingly criticized because they lack sufficient functional basis. To include functional information into these models, we integrated two concepts from community ecology into a new type of HDM. We incorporated: 1) species selection by their traits in which only those species that pass the environmental filter can be part of the community (assembly theory); 2) that the occurrence probability of a community is determined by the extent to which the community mean traits fit the required traits as set by the environment. In this paper, our trait-based HDM is presented and its predictive capacity explored. Our approach consists of two steps. In step 1, four plant traits (stem-specific density and indicator values for nutrients, moisture and acidity) are predicted from four dominant environmental drivers (disturbance, nutrient supply, moisture supply and acidity) using regression. In step 2, these traits are used to predict the occurrence probability of 13 vegetation types, covering the majority of vegetation types across the Netherlands. The model was validated by comparison to the observed vegetation type for 263 plots in the Netherlands. Model performance was within the range of conventional HDMs and decreased with increasing uncertainty in the environment-trait relationships and with an increasing number of vegetation types. This study shows that including functionality into HDMs is not necessarily at the cost of model performance, while it has several conceptual advantages among including an increased insight in the functional characteristics of the vegetation and sources of unpredictability in community assembly. As such it is a promising first step towards more functional HDMs. Further development of a trait-based HDM hinges on replacing indicator values by truly functional traits and the translation of these relationships into mechanistic relationships.",
author = "Douma, {Jacob C.} and Witte, {Jan Philip M.} and Rien Aerts and Bartholomeus, {Ruud P.} and Ordo{\~n}ez, {Jenny C.} and Venterink, {Harry Olde} and Wassen, {Martin J.} and {van Bodegom}, {Peter M.}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1111/j.1600-0587.2011.07140.x",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "294--305",
journal = "Ecography",
issn = "0906-7590",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "4",

}

Towards a functional basis for predicting vegetation patterns; incorporating plant traits in habitat distribution models. / Douma, Jacob C.; Witte, Jan Philip M.; Aerts, Rien; Bartholomeus, Ruud P.; Ordoñez, Jenny C.; Venterink, Harry Olde; Wassen, Martin J.; van Bodegom, Peter M.

In: Ecography, Vol. 35, No. 4, 04.2012, p. 294-305.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards a functional basis for predicting vegetation patterns; incorporating plant traits in habitat distribution models

AU - Douma, Jacob C.

AU - Witte, Jan Philip M.

AU - Aerts, Rien

AU - Bartholomeus, Ruud P.

AU - Ordoñez, Jenny C.

AU - Venterink, Harry Olde

AU - Wassen, Martin J.

AU - van Bodegom, Peter M.

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - Reliably predicting vegetation distribution requires habitat distribution models (HDMs) that are ecologically sound. Current correlative HDMs are increasingly criticized because they lack sufficient functional basis. To include functional information into these models, we integrated two concepts from community ecology into a new type of HDM. We incorporated: 1) species selection by their traits in which only those species that pass the environmental filter can be part of the community (assembly theory); 2) that the occurrence probability of a community is determined by the extent to which the community mean traits fit the required traits as set by the environment. In this paper, our trait-based HDM is presented and its predictive capacity explored. Our approach consists of two steps. In step 1, four plant traits (stem-specific density and indicator values for nutrients, moisture and acidity) are predicted from four dominant environmental drivers (disturbance, nutrient supply, moisture supply and acidity) using regression. In step 2, these traits are used to predict the occurrence probability of 13 vegetation types, covering the majority of vegetation types across the Netherlands. The model was validated by comparison to the observed vegetation type for 263 plots in the Netherlands. Model performance was within the range of conventional HDMs and decreased with increasing uncertainty in the environment-trait relationships and with an increasing number of vegetation types. This study shows that including functionality into HDMs is not necessarily at the cost of model performance, while it has several conceptual advantages among including an increased insight in the functional characteristics of the vegetation and sources of unpredictability in community assembly. As such it is a promising first step towards more functional HDMs. Further development of a trait-based HDM hinges on replacing indicator values by truly functional traits and the translation of these relationships into mechanistic relationships.

AB - Reliably predicting vegetation distribution requires habitat distribution models (HDMs) that are ecologically sound. Current correlative HDMs are increasingly criticized because they lack sufficient functional basis. To include functional information into these models, we integrated two concepts from community ecology into a new type of HDM. We incorporated: 1) species selection by their traits in which only those species that pass the environmental filter can be part of the community (assembly theory); 2) that the occurrence probability of a community is determined by the extent to which the community mean traits fit the required traits as set by the environment. In this paper, our trait-based HDM is presented and its predictive capacity explored. Our approach consists of two steps. In step 1, four plant traits (stem-specific density and indicator values for nutrients, moisture and acidity) are predicted from four dominant environmental drivers (disturbance, nutrient supply, moisture supply and acidity) using regression. In step 2, these traits are used to predict the occurrence probability of 13 vegetation types, covering the majority of vegetation types across the Netherlands. The model was validated by comparison to the observed vegetation type for 263 plots in the Netherlands. Model performance was within the range of conventional HDMs and decreased with increasing uncertainty in the environment-trait relationships and with an increasing number of vegetation types. This study shows that including functionality into HDMs is not necessarily at the cost of model performance, while it has several conceptual advantages among including an increased insight in the functional characteristics of the vegetation and sources of unpredictability in community assembly. As such it is a promising first step towards more functional HDMs. Further development of a trait-based HDM hinges on replacing indicator values by truly functional traits and the translation of these relationships into mechanistic relationships.

U2 - 10.1111/j.1600-0587.2011.07140.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1600-0587.2011.07140.x

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 294

EP - 305

JO - Ecography

T2 - Ecography

JF - Ecography

SN - 0906-7590

IS - 4

ER -