State paternalism and institutional degradation at Treesleeper Eco-camp: Community-based tourism and the loss of sovereignty among Bushmen in Namibia

Stasja Koot*, Verina Jane Ingram, Mariska Bijsterbosch

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

The Namibian government promotes community-based tourism (CBT) as market-based development. At Treesleeper Eco-camp, a CBT-project among marginalised Hai//om and !Xun Bushmen (San), we investigate how Bushmen's historically developed paternalist relations shape contemporary local institutional processes. Institutional design principles, seen as prerequisites for stable and robust institutions (norms, rules and regulations), and thus successful CBT, are used to analyse local changes of the project in relation to a government grant. Ironically, after the grant, Treesleeper generated less income and the consequent ‘upgrade’ intensified conflicts. This study shows that community control, ownership and participation are key factors for successful CBT-projects, but currently the state has obstructed these, just as various other ‘superior’ actors have also done (throughout history) in relation to ‘inferior’ Bushmen. We argue that paternalist ideologies perpetuate today in the Bushmen's relation with the state, leading to weaker institutions locally through dispossession of their sovereignty.

Original languageEnglish
JournalDevelopment Southern Africa
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 3 Oct 2019

Fingerprint

paternalism
Namibia
sovereignty
tourism
Tourism
community
grant
ideology
ownership
Ideologies
income
market
loss
camp
regulation
history
participation
project

Keywords

  • Bushmen
  • Community-based tourism
  • institutional design principles
  • Namibia
  • state paternalism

Cite this

@article{99d9861d0748423598561d79420b6773,
title = "State paternalism and institutional degradation at Treesleeper Eco-camp: Community-based tourism and the loss of sovereignty among Bushmen in Namibia",
abstract = "The Namibian government promotes community-based tourism (CBT) as market-based development. At Treesleeper Eco-camp, a CBT-project among marginalised Hai//om and !Xun Bushmen (San), we investigate how Bushmen's historically developed paternalist relations shape contemporary local institutional processes. Institutional design principles, seen as prerequisites for stable and robust institutions (norms, rules and regulations), and thus successful CBT, are used to analyse local changes of the project in relation to a government grant. Ironically, after the grant, Treesleeper generated less income and the consequent ‘upgrade’ intensified conflicts. This study shows that community control, ownership and participation are key factors for successful CBT-projects, but currently the state has obstructed these, just as various other ‘superior’ actors have also done (throughout history) in relation to ‘inferior’ Bushmen. We argue that paternalist ideologies perpetuate today in the Bushmen's relation with the state, leading to weaker institutions locally through dispossession of their sovereignty.",
keywords = "Bushmen, Community-based tourism, institutional design principles, Namibia, state paternalism",
author = "Stasja Koot and Ingram, {Verina Jane} and Mariska Bijsterbosch",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/0376835X.2019.1674636",
language = "English",
journal = "Development Southern Africa",
issn = "0376-835X",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - State paternalism and institutional degradation at Treesleeper Eco-camp: Community-based tourism and the loss of sovereignty among Bushmen in Namibia

AU - Koot, Stasja

AU - Ingram, Verina Jane

AU - Bijsterbosch, Mariska

PY - 2019/10/3

Y1 - 2019/10/3

N2 - The Namibian government promotes community-based tourism (CBT) as market-based development. At Treesleeper Eco-camp, a CBT-project among marginalised Hai//om and !Xun Bushmen (San), we investigate how Bushmen's historically developed paternalist relations shape contemporary local institutional processes. Institutional design principles, seen as prerequisites for stable and robust institutions (norms, rules and regulations), and thus successful CBT, are used to analyse local changes of the project in relation to a government grant. Ironically, after the grant, Treesleeper generated less income and the consequent ‘upgrade’ intensified conflicts. This study shows that community control, ownership and participation are key factors for successful CBT-projects, but currently the state has obstructed these, just as various other ‘superior’ actors have also done (throughout history) in relation to ‘inferior’ Bushmen. We argue that paternalist ideologies perpetuate today in the Bushmen's relation with the state, leading to weaker institutions locally through dispossession of their sovereignty.

AB - The Namibian government promotes community-based tourism (CBT) as market-based development. At Treesleeper Eco-camp, a CBT-project among marginalised Hai//om and !Xun Bushmen (San), we investigate how Bushmen's historically developed paternalist relations shape contemporary local institutional processes. Institutional design principles, seen as prerequisites for stable and robust institutions (norms, rules and regulations), and thus successful CBT, are used to analyse local changes of the project in relation to a government grant. Ironically, after the grant, Treesleeper generated less income and the consequent ‘upgrade’ intensified conflicts. This study shows that community control, ownership and participation are key factors for successful CBT-projects, but currently the state has obstructed these, just as various other ‘superior’ actors have also done (throughout history) in relation to ‘inferior’ Bushmen. We argue that paternalist ideologies perpetuate today in the Bushmen's relation with the state, leading to weaker institutions locally through dispossession of their sovereignty.

KW - Bushmen

KW - Community-based tourism

KW - institutional design principles

KW - Namibia

KW - state paternalism

U2 - 10.1080/0376835X.2019.1674636

DO - 10.1080/0376835X.2019.1674636

M3 - Article

JO - Development Southern Africa

JF - Development Southern Africa

SN - 0376-835X

ER -