Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes

Emiel De Lombaerde*, Kris Verheyen, Michael P. Perring, Markus Bernhardt-Römermann, Hans Van Calster, Jörg Brunet, Markéta Chudomelová, Guillaume Decocq, Martin Diekmann, Tomasz Durak, Radim Hédl, Thilo Heinken, Patrick Hommel, Bogdan Jaroszewicz, Martin Kopecký, Jonathan Lenoir, Martin Macek, František Máliš, Fraser J.G. Mitchell, Tobias Naaf & 8 others Miles Newman, Petr Petřík, Kamila Reczyńska, Wolfgang Schmidt, Krzysztof Świerkosz, Ondřej Vild, Monika Wulf, Lander Baeten

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Understorey plant communities play a key role in the functioning of forest ecosystems. Under favourable environmental conditions, competitive understorey species may develop high abundances and influence important ecosystem processes such as tree regeneration. Thus, understanding and predicting the response of competitive understorey species as a function of changing environmental conditions is important for forest managers. In the absence of sufficient temporal data to quantify actual vegetation changes, space-for-time (SFT) substitution is often used, i.e. studies that use environmental gradients across space to infer vegetation responses to environmental change over time. Here we assess the validity of such SFT approaches and analysed 36 resurvey studies from ancient forests with low levels of recent disturbances across temperate Europe to assess how six competitive understorey plant species respond to gradients of overstorey cover, soil conditions, atmospheric N deposition and climatic conditions over space and time. The combination of historical and contemporary surveys allows (i) to test if observed contemporary patterns across space are consistent at the time of the historical survey, and, crucially, (ii) to assess whether changes in abundance over time given recorded environmental change match expectations from patterns recorded along environmental gradients in space. We found consistent spatial relationships at the two periods: local variation in soil variables and overstorey cover were the best predictors of individual species’ cover while interregional variation in coarse-scale variables, i.e. N deposition and climate, was less important. However, we found that our SFT approach could not accurately explain the large variation in abundance changes over time. We thus recommend to be cautious when using SFT substitution to infer species responses to temporal changes.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)52-64
JournalBasic and Applied Ecology
Volume30
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

environmental gradient
understory
overstory
environmental factors
vegetation
forest ecosystems
space and time
plant communities
soil quality
managers
environmental change
substitution
climate
environmental conditions
ecosystems
soil
forest ecosystem
plant community
testing
regeneration

Keywords

  • Canopy
  • Chronosequence
  • Cover abundance
  • forestREplot
  • Global change
  • Herb layer
  • Nitrogen deposition
  • Spatiotemporal resurvey data
  • Temperate forest
  • Tree regeneration

Cite this

De Lombaerde, E., Verheyen, K., Perring, M. P., Bernhardt-Römermann, M., Van Calster, H., Brunet, J., ... Baeten, L. (2018). Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes. Basic and Applied Ecology, 30, 52-64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.baae.2018.05.013
De Lombaerde, Emiel ; Verheyen, Kris ; Perring, Michael P. ; Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus ; Van Calster, Hans ; Brunet, Jörg ; Chudomelová, Markéta ; Decocq, Guillaume ; Diekmann, Martin ; Durak, Tomasz ; Hédl, Radim ; Heinken, Thilo ; Hommel, Patrick ; Jaroszewicz, Bogdan ; Kopecký, Martin ; Lenoir, Jonathan ; Macek, Martin ; Máliš, František ; Mitchell, Fraser J.G. ; Naaf, Tobias ; Newman, Miles ; Petřík, Petr ; Reczyńska, Kamila ; Schmidt, Wolfgang ; Świerkosz, Krzysztof ; Vild, Ondřej ; Wulf, Monika ; Baeten, Lander. / Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes. In: Basic and Applied Ecology. 2018 ; Vol. 30. pp. 52-64.
@article{7282cdf5f4ec47df9cb6c36321c71b6a,
title = "Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes",
abstract = "Understorey plant communities play a key role in the functioning of forest ecosystems. Under favourable environmental conditions, competitive understorey species may develop high abundances and influence important ecosystem processes such as tree regeneration. Thus, understanding and predicting the response of competitive understorey species as a function of changing environmental conditions is important for forest managers. In the absence of sufficient temporal data to quantify actual vegetation changes, space-for-time (SFT) substitution is often used, i.e. studies that use environmental gradients across space to infer vegetation responses to environmental change over time. Here we assess the validity of such SFT approaches and analysed 36 resurvey studies from ancient forests with low levels of recent disturbances across temperate Europe to assess how six competitive understorey plant species respond to gradients of overstorey cover, soil conditions, atmospheric N deposition and climatic conditions over space and time. The combination of historical and contemporary surveys allows (i) to test if observed contemporary patterns across space are consistent at the time of the historical survey, and, crucially, (ii) to assess whether changes in abundance over time given recorded environmental change match expectations from patterns recorded along environmental gradients in space. We found consistent spatial relationships at the two periods: local variation in soil variables and overstorey cover were the best predictors of individual species’ cover while interregional variation in coarse-scale variables, i.e. N deposition and climate, was less important. However, we found that our SFT approach could not accurately explain the large variation in abundance changes over time. We thus recommend to be cautious when using SFT substitution to infer species responses to temporal changes.",
keywords = "Canopy, Chronosequence, Cover abundance, forestREplot, Global change, Herb layer, Nitrogen deposition, Spatiotemporal resurvey data, Temperate forest, Tree regeneration",
author = "{De Lombaerde}, Emiel and Kris Verheyen and Perring, {Michael P.} and Markus Bernhardt-R{\"o}mermann and {Van Calster}, Hans and J{\"o}rg Brunet and Mark{\'e}ta Chudomelov{\'a} and Guillaume Decocq and Martin Diekmann and Tomasz Durak and Radim H{\'e}dl and Thilo Heinken and Patrick Hommel and Bogdan Jaroszewicz and Martin Kopeck{\'y} and Jonathan Lenoir and Martin Macek and František M{\'a}liš and Mitchell, {Fraser J.G.} and Tobias Naaf and Miles Newman and Petr Petř{\'i}k and Kamila Reczyńska and Wolfgang Schmidt and Krzysztof Świerkosz and Ondřej Vild and Monika Wulf and Lander Baeten",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.baae.2018.05.013",
language = "English",
volume = "30",
pages = "52--64",
journal = "Basic and Applied Ecology",
issn = "1439-1791",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

De Lombaerde, E, Verheyen, K, Perring, MP, Bernhardt-Römermann, M, Van Calster, H, Brunet, J, Chudomelová, M, Decocq, G, Diekmann, M, Durak, T, Hédl, R, Heinken, T, Hommel, P, Jaroszewicz, B, Kopecký, M, Lenoir, J, Macek, M, Máliš, F, Mitchell, FJG, Naaf, T, Newman, M, Petřík, P, Reczyńska, K, Schmidt, W, Świerkosz, K, Vild, O, Wulf, M & Baeten, L 2018, 'Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes', Basic and Applied Ecology, vol. 30, pp. 52-64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.baae.2018.05.013

Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes. / De Lombaerde, Emiel; Verheyen, Kris; Perring, Michael P.; Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus; Van Calster, Hans; Brunet, Jörg; Chudomelová, Markéta; Decocq, Guillaume; Diekmann, Martin; Durak, Tomasz; Hédl, Radim; Heinken, Thilo; Hommel, Patrick; Jaroszewicz, Bogdan; Kopecký, Martin; Lenoir, Jonathan; Macek, Martin; Máliš, František; Mitchell, Fraser J.G.; Naaf, Tobias; Newman, Miles; Petřík, Petr; Reczyńska, Kamila; Schmidt, Wolfgang; Świerkosz, Krzysztof; Vild, Ondřej; Wulf, Monika; Baeten, Lander.

In: Basic and Applied Ecology, Vol. 30, 01.08.2018, p. 52-64.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Responses of competitive understorey species to spatial environmental gradients inaccurately explain temporal changes

AU - De Lombaerde, Emiel

AU - Verheyen, Kris

AU - Perring, Michael P.

AU - Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus

AU - Van Calster, Hans

AU - Brunet, Jörg

AU - Chudomelová, Markéta

AU - Decocq, Guillaume

AU - Diekmann, Martin

AU - Durak, Tomasz

AU - Hédl, Radim

AU - Heinken, Thilo

AU - Hommel, Patrick

AU - Jaroszewicz, Bogdan

AU - Kopecký, Martin

AU - Lenoir, Jonathan

AU - Macek, Martin

AU - Máliš, František

AU - Mitchell, Fraser J.G.

AU - Naaf, Tobias

AU - Newman, Miles

AU - Petřík, Petr

AU - Reczyńska, Kamila

AU - Schmidt, Wolfgang

AU - Świerkosz, Krzysztof

AU - Vild, Ondřej

AU - Wulf, Monika

AU - Baeten, Lander

PY - 2018/8/1

Y1 - 2018/8/1

N2 - Understorey plant communities play a key role in the functioning of forest ecosystems. Under favourable environmental conditions, competitive understorey species may develop high abundances and influence important ecosystem processes such as tree regeneration. Thus, understanding and predicting the response of competitive understorey species as a function of changing environmental conditions is important for forest managers. In the absence of sufficient temporal data to quantify actual vegetation changes, space-for-time (SFT) substitution is often used, i.e. studies that use environmental gradients across space to infer vegetation responses to environmental change over time. Here we assess the validity of such SFT approaches and analysed 36 resurvey studies from ancient forests with low levels of recent disturbances across temperate Europe to assess how six competitive understorey plant species respond to gradients of overstorey cover, soil conditions, atmospheric N deposition and climatic conditions over space and time. The combination of historical and contemporary surveys allows (i) to test if observed contemporary patterns across space are consistent at the time of the historical survey, and, crucially, (ii) to assess whether changes in abundance over time given recorded environmental change match expectations from patterns recorded along environmental gradients in space. We found consistent spatial relationships at the two periods: local variation in soil variables and overstorey cover were the best predictors of individual species’ cover while interregional variation in coarse-scale variables, i.e. N deposition and climate, was less important. However, we found that our SFT approach could not accurately explain the large variation in abundance changes over time. We thus recommend to be cautious when using SFT substitution to infer species responses to temporal changes.

AB - Understorey plant communities play a key role in the functioning of forest ecosystems. Under favourable environmental conditions, competitive understorey species may develop high abundances and influence important ecosystem processes such as tree regeneration. Thus, understanding and predicting the response of competitive understorey species as a function of changing environmental conditions is important for forest managers. In the absence of sufficient temporal data to quantify actual vegetation changes, space-for-time (SFT) substitution is often used, i.e. studies that use environmental gradients across space to infer vegetation responses to environmental change over time. Here we assess the validity of such SFT approaches and analysed 36 resurvey studies from ancient forests with low levels of recent disturbances across temperate Europe to assess how six competitive understorey plant species respond to gradients of overstorey cover, soil conditions, atmospheric N deposition and climatic conditions over space and time. The combination of historical and contemporary surveys allows (i) to test if observed contemporary patterns across space are consistent at the time of the historical survey, and, crucially, (ii) to assess whether changes in abundance over time given recorded environmental change match expectations from patterns recorded along environmental gradients in space. We found consistent spatial relationships at the two periods: local variation in soil variables and overstorey cover were the best predictors of individual species’ cover while interregional variation in coarse-scale variables, i.e. N deposition and climate, was less important. However, we found that our SFT approach could not accurately explain the large variation in abundance changes over time. We thus recommend to be cautious when using SFT substitution to infer species responses to temporal changes.

KW - Canopy

KW - Chronosequence

KW - Cover abundance

KW - forestREplot

KW - Global change

KW - Herb layer

KW - Nitrogen deposition

KW - Spatiotemporal resurvey data

KW - Temperate forest

KW - Tree regeneration

U2 - 10.1016/j.baae.2018.05.013

DO - 10.1016/j.baae.2018.05.013

M3 - Article

VL - 30

SP - 52

EP - 64

JO - Basic and Applied Ecology

JF - Basic and Applied Ecology

SN - 1439-1791

ER -