Reading landscape design representations as an interplay of validity, readability and interactivity: a framework for visual content analysis

K.M.C. Raaphorst, Gerda Roeleveld, I. Duchhart, W.G.M. van der Knaap, A. van den Brink

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Considering the importance of visual representations for communication between stakeholders in landscape planning and design processes, the authors identify a lack of critical visual research methods supportive of the disciplines involved. As part of such a method, they have developed an analytical framework based on semiotic and iconographic theory that enables a visual content analysis and iconographic interpretation of landscape design representations. Two projects from Rebuild by Design, a participatory transdisciplinary design competition organized in the New York City area after hurricane Sandy, were analysed to demonstrate this framework. The article presents a semiotic vocabulary based on four categories: medium, mode, formulation and knowledge with which to ‘read’, discuss and potentially create design representations. This enables a syntactic analysis for assessing the semiotic complexity of design representations in terms of validity, readability and interactivity. This assessment enables further qualitative study of the production and interpretation of landscape design representations in practice.
Original languageEnglish
JournalVisual Communication
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 11 Jun 2018

Fingerprint

interactive media
content analysis
semiotics
Semiotics
landscape planning
interpretation
transdisciplinary
research method
vocabulary
Hurricanes
Syntactics
stakeholder
Readability
Interactivity
Content Analysis
Landscape Design
communication
lack
Planning
Communication

Cite this

@article{b064423e91fd4b3e98bd6ee5a742ec6d,
title = "Reading landscape design representations as an interplay of validity, readability and interactivity: a framework for visual content analysis",
abstract = "Considering the importance of visual representations for communication between stakeholders in landscape planning and design processes, the authors identify a lack of critical visual research methods supportive of the disciplines involved. As part of such a method, they have developed an analytical framework based on semiotic and iconographic theory that enables a visual content analysis and iconographic interpretation of landscape design representations. Two projects from Rebuild by Design, a participatory transdisciplinary design competition organized in the New York City area after hurricane Sandy, were analysed to demonstrate this framework. The article presents a semiotic vocabulary based on four categories: medium, mode, formulation and knowledge with which to ‘read’, discuss and potentially create design representations. This enables a syntactic analysis for assessing the semiotic complexity of design representations in terms of validity, readability and interactivity. This assessment enables further qualitative study of the production and interpretation of landscape design representations in practice.",
author = "K.M.C. Raaphorst and Gerda Roeleveld and I. Duchhart and {van der Knaap}, W.G.M. and {van den Brink}, A.",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "11",
doi = "10.1177/1470357218779103",
language = "English",
journal = "Visual Communication",
issn = "1470-3572",
publisher = "Sage",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reading landscape design representations as an interplay of validity, readability and interactivity: a framework for visual content analysis

AU - Raaphorst, K.M.C.

AU - Roeleveld, Gerda

AU - Duchhart, I.

AU - van der Knaap, W.G.M.

AU - van den Brink, A.

PY - 2018/6/11

Y1 - 2018/6/11

N2 - Considering the importance of visual representations for communication between stakeholders in landscape planning and design processes, the authors identify a lack of critical visual research methods supportive of the disciplines involved. As part of such a method, they have developed an analytical framework based on semiotic and iconographic theory that enables a visual content analysis and iconographic interpretation of landscape design representations. Two projects from Rebuild by Design, a participatory transdisciplinary design competition organized in the New York City area after hurricane Sandy, were analysed to demonstrate this framework. The article presents a semiotic vocabulary based on four categories: medium, mode, formulation and knowledge with which to ‘read’, discuss and potentially create design representations. This enables a syntactic analysis for assessing the semiotic complexity of design representations in terms of validity, readability and interactivity. This assessment enables further qualitative study of the production and interpretation of landscape design representations in practice.

AB - Considering the importance of visual representations for communication between stakeholders in landscape planning and design processes, the authors identify a lack of critical visual research methods supportive of the disciplines involved. As part of such a method, they have developed an analytical framework based on semiotic and iconographic theory that enables a visual content analysis and iconographic interpretation of landscape design representations. Two projects from Rebuild by Design, a participatory transdisciplinary design competition organized in the New York City area after hurricane Sandy, were analysed to demonstrate this framework. The article presents a semiotic vocabulary based on four categories: medium, mode, formulation and knowledge with which to ‘read’, discuss and potentially create design representations. This enables a syntactic analysis for assessing the semiotic complexity of design representations in terms of validity, readability and interactivity. This assessment enables further qualitative study of the production and interpretation of landscape design representations in practice.

U2 - 10.1177/1470357218779103

DO - 10.1177/1470357218779103

M3 - Article

JO - Visual Communication

JF - Visual Communication

SN - 1470-3572

ER -