Policy Studies of Policy Conflicts: a Deliberative Approach for Knowledge Integration

T.A.P. Metze, Jennifer Dodge

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference paperAcademic

Abstract

In policy studies, the study of policy controversies is an emerging field. For example, Weible and Heikkila (2017) observe that policy scholars often treat conflict as a “background concept” and study conflict indirectly as protest mobilization, competing values, or other political activities. However, recently, researchers have taken up policy controversies and policy conflict as a phenomenon in itself. Weible and Heikkila (2017) propose a comprehensive ‘Policy Conflict Framework’ (PCF) and for example Wolf and Van Dooren published a series of articles on policy conflict escalation (see for instance Wolf and Van Dooren 2017). These two research efforts have a different approach to policy conflict, which reflects the bigger debate in policy studies between structural approaches such as the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) (Weible and Sabatier 2007) and interpretive approaches that are rooted in the analysis of interaction, arguments, and meaning (Rein & Schön 1996, Hajer 1995; Fischer 2003). In this paper(-writing-process), we aim for bridging gaps and appreciating differences between these approaches and the communities that work within them. Perhaps we can even identify knowledge gaps related to understanding policy conflicts that we may want to address to build knowledge in the field. We will begin by sharing an initial, short paper with participants that proposes 1) a process by which we can apply principles of deliberation, learning and reflexivity during two meetings in our joint sessions in order to better understand differences, similarities, and complementarities of the approaches within policy studies, and 2) an initial set of topics for possible discussion related to these differences, similarities and complementarities.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationECPR 2020 Toulouse Joint Sessions
Publication statusPublished - 2020
EventECPR 2020 Toulouse Joint Sessions (online) - online
Duration: 14 Apr 202017 Apr 2020
https://ecpr.eu/Events/AcademicProgramme/PanelList/129

Conference

ConferenceECPR 2020 Toulouse Joint Sessions (online)
Period14/04/2017/04/20
Internet address

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Policy Studies of Policy Conflicts: a Deliberative Approach for Knowledge Integration'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this