Nutritional impact on molecular and physiological adaptations to exercise : nutrition matters

Pim Knuiman

Research output: Thesisinternal PhD, WU

Abstract

Skeletal muscle responds to exercise by a diversity of processes that collectively contribute to short-term and structural adaptations to the demanded performance capacities. There is common consensus that, in general, adequate nutrient availability during and after exercise is important to maximise skeletal muscle adaptation and ultimately performance. At the same time, several knowledge gaps remain regarding the precise mechanisms underlying these effects on adaptation, the most optimal nutrient composition in relation to type of exercise, optimal timing etc.  

This dissertation addresses some of these unsolved issues by studying the role of carbohydrates and proteins during adaptation following different forms of exercise. The first part (chapters 2 – 4) focusses on carbohydrate availability with resistance exercise, whereas the second part (chapters 5 - 7) specifically addresses the effects and potential of protein supplementation with endurance training. In chapter 2 we reviewed the existing literature regarding the role of skeletal muscle glycogen with endurance and resistance exercise. Based on this review we concluded that the role of muscle glycogen levels and/or carbohydrate availability on the skeletal muscle adaptive response to resistance exercise requires further scientific attention. To experimentally explore this, we assessed the impact of a pre-exercise meal that differed in macronutrient content on skeletal muscle glycogen levels and acute transcriptional level analysing specific mRNAs in the post-resistance exercise period in chapter 3. Specifically, after a glycogen depleting endurance exercise session in the morning, subjects received an isocaloric mixed meal containing different amounts of carbohydrates and fat 2 hours before a resistance exercise session in the afternoon, while ample protein was provided throughout the day. We hypothesized that some of the selected mRNAs associated with substrate metabolism and mitochondrial biogenesis would differ between the nutritional conditions, without any changes in proteolytic genes. The findings described in  chapter 3 demonstrated that muscle mRNA responses related to exercise adaptation were minimally affected by the pre-exercise meals that differed in macronutrient composition. In chapter 4, derived from the same study, we describe the analysis of a number of plasma cytokine patterns during the day to investigate  whether these mediators were affected by carbohydrate availability. We hypothesized that some selected cytokines would  differ between nutritional conditions, whereas other circulating cytokines  suggested to be involved  in skeletal muscle adaptation would  not respond differently. Our main finding  was that a pre-exercise meal in general did not influence plasma cytokine responses in the post-resistance exercise period. Findings of chapter 3 and 4 contribute to the view that carbohydrate availability during resistance exercise is of minor importance when aiming for an acute positive skeletal muscle adaptive response. In addition, our data question the importance of carbohydrates as both substrate for resistance exercise and as modulator of the skeletal muscle response that underlies adaptation. Yet, at present it might be premature to change carbohydrate recommendations for individuals performing resistance exercise. Shifting our focus to proteins, we first reviewed the effects and possible underlying physiological mechanisms of protein supplementation on the adaptive response to endurance training in Chapter 5. To further explore these insights, we performed a double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures to determine whether protein supplementation impacts the adaptive response to endurance training. In chapter 6 we provide  proof-of-concept that protein supplementation elicited greater increases in VO2max and stimulated lean mass gain in response to prolonged endurance training. To our knowledge, this was the first double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures showing that protein supplementation enhances the adaptive response to endurance training. These remarkable effects of protein on VO2max that were observed give rise to questions regarding their underlying mechanisms. To this end, we analysed the muscle transcriptome to gain insight into changes in the steady-state gene expression. In chapter 7, we demonstrated that prolonged endurance training changed expression of genes involved in extracellular matrix organisation, energy metabolism and oxidative phosphorylation. Changes in extracellular matrix organisation tended to be greater in the protein group than in the control group and these greater transcriptional changes may reflect the enhanced physiological adaptation as a result of protein supplementation.

Original languageEnglish
QualificationDoctor of Philosophy
Awarding Institution
  • Wageningen University
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Witkamp, Renger, Promotor
  • Hopman, M.T.E., Promotor, External person
  • Mensink, Marco, Co-promotor
  • Wouters, J.A., Co-promotor, External person
Award date11 Oct 2019
Place of PublicationWageningen
Publisher
Print ISBNs9789463950060
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

Physiological Adaptation
Skeletal Muscle
Carbohydrates
Proteins
Glycogen
Meals
Cytokines
Muscles
Messenger RNA
Extracellular Matrix
Randomized Controlled Trials
Gene Expression
Food
Oxidative Phosphorylation
Organelle Biogenesis
Transcriptome
Energy Metabolism
Fats

Cite this

Knuiman, Pim. / Nutritional impact on molecular and physiological adaptations to exercise : nutrition matters. Wageningen : Wageningen University, 2019. 191 p.
@phdthesis{66bd7c23310e4d999235fb7f8275da06,
title = "Nutritional impact on molecular and physiological adaptations to exercise : nutrition matters",
abstract = "Skeletal muscle responds to exercise by a diversity of processes that collectively contribute to short-term and structural adaptations to the demanded performance capacities. There is common consensus that, in general, adequate nutrient availability during and after exercise is important to maximise skeletal muscle adaptation and ultimately performance. At the same time, several knowledge gaps remain regarding the precise mechanisms underlying these effects on adaptation, the most optimal nutrient composition in relation to type of exercise, optimal timing etc.   This dissertation addresses some of these unsolved issues by studying the role of carbohydrates and proteins during adaptation following different forms of exercise. The first part (chapters 2 – 4) focusses on carbohydrate availability with resistance exercise, whereas the second part (chapters 5 - 7) specifically addresses the effects and potential of protein supplementation with endurance training. In chapter 2 we reviewed the existing literature regarding the role of skeletal muscle glycogen with endurance and resistance exercise. Based on this review we concluded that the role of muscle glycogen levels and/or carbohydrate availability on the skeletal muscle adaptive response to resistance exercise requires further scientific attention. To experimentally explore this, we assessed the impact of a pre-exercise meal that differed in macronutrient content on skeletal muscle glycogen levels and acute transcriptional level analysing specific mRNAs in the post-resistance exercise period in chapter 3. Specifically, after a glycogen depleting endurance exercise session in the morning, subjects received an isocaloric mixed meal containing different amounts of carbohydrates and fat 2 hours before a resistance exercise session in the afternoon, while ample protein was provided throughout the day. We hypothesized that some of the selected mRNAs associated with substrate metabolism and mitochondrial biogenesis would differ between the nutritional conditions, without any changes in proteolytic genes. The findings described in  chapter 3 demonstrated that muscle mRNA responses related to exercise adaptation were minimally affected by the pre-exercise meals that differed in macronutrient composition. In chapter 4, derived from the same study, we describe the analysis of a number of plasma cytokine patterns during the day to investigate  whether these mediators were affected by carbohydrate availability. We hypothesized that some selected cytokines would  differ between nutritional conditions, whereas other circulating cytokines  suggested to be involved  in skeletal muscle adaptation would  not respond differently. Our main finding  was that a pre-exercise meal in general did not influence plasma cytokine responses in the post-resistance exercise period. Findings of chapter 3 and 4 contribute to the view that carbohydrate availability during resistance exercise is of minor importance when aiming for an acute positive skeletal muscle adaptive response. In addition, our data question the importance of carbohydrates as both substrate for resistance exercise and as modulator of the skeletal muscle response that underlies adaptation. Yet, at present it might be premature to change carbohydrate recommendations for individuals performing resistance exercise. Shifting our focus to proteins, we first reviewed the effects and possible underlying physiological mechanisms of protein supplementation on the adaptive response to endurance training in Chapter 5. To further explore these insights, we performed a double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures to determine whether protein supplementation impacts the adaptive response to endurance training. In chapter 6 we provide  proof-of-concept that protein supplementation elicited greater increases in VO2max and stimulated lean mass gain in response to prolonged endurance training. To our knowledge, this was the first double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures showing that protein supplementation enhances the adaptive response to endurance training. These remarkable effects of protein on VO2max that were observed give rise to questions regarding their underlying mechanisms. To this end, we analysed the muscle transcriptome to gain insight into changes in the steady-state gene expression. In chapter 7, we demonstrated that prolonged endurance training changed expression of genes involved in extracellular matrix organisation, energy metabolism and oxidative phosphorylation. Changes in extracellular matrix organisation tended to be greater in the protein group than in the control group and these greater transcriptional changes may reflect the enhanced physiological adaptation as a result of protein supplementation.",
author = "Pim Knuiman",
note = "WU thesis 7331 Includes bibliographical references. - With summary in English",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.18174/479016",
language = "English",
isbn = "9789463950060",
publisher = "Wageningen University",
school = "Wageningen University",

}

Nutritional impact on molecular and physiological adaptations to exercise : nutrition matters. / Knuiman, Pim.

Wageningen : Wageningen University, 2019. 191 p.

Research output: Thesisinternal PhD, WU

TY - THES

T1 - Nutritional impact on molecular and physiological adaptations to exercise : nutrition matters

AU - Knuiman, Pim

N1 - WU thesis 7331 Includes bibliographical references. - With summary in English

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Skeletal muscle responds to exercise by a diversity of processes that collectively contribute to short-term and structural adaptations to the demanded performance capacities. There is common consensus that, in general, adequate nutrient availability during and after exercise is important to maximise skeletal muscle adaptation and ultimately performance. At the same time, several knowledge gaps remain regarding the precise mechanisms underlying these effects on adaptation, the most optimal nutrient composition in relation to type of exercise, optimal timing etc.   This dissertation addresses some of these unsolved issues by studying the role of carbohydrates and proteins during adaptation following different forms of exercise. The first part (chapters 2 – 4) focusses on carbohydrate availability with resistance exercise, whereas the second part (chapters 5 - 7) specifically addresses the effects and potential of protein supplementation with endurance training. In chapter 2 we reviewed the existing literature regarding the role of skeletal muscle glycogen with endurance and resistance exercise. Based on this review we concluded that the role of muscle glycogen levels and/or carbohydrate availability on the skeletal muscle adaptive response to resistance exercise requires further scientific attention. To experimentally explore this, we assessed the impact of a pre-exercise meal that differed in macronutrient content on skeletal muscle glycogen levels and acute transcriptional level analysing specific mRNAs in the post-resistance exercise period in chapter 3. Specifically, after a glycogen depleting endurance exercise session in the morning, subjects received an isocaloric mixed meal containing different amounts of carbohydrates and fat 2 hours before a resistance exercise session in the afternoon, while ample protein was provided throughout the day. We hypothesized that some of the selected mRNAs associated with substrate metabolism and mitochondrial biogenesis would differ between the nutritional conditions, without any changes in proteolytic genes. The findings described in  chapter 3 demonstrated that muscle mRNA responses related to exercise adaptation were minimally affected by the pre-exercise meals that differed in macronutrient composition. In chapter 4, derived from the same study, we describe the analysis of a number of plasma cytokine patterns during the day to investigate  whether these mediators were affected by carbohydrate availability. We hypothesized that some selected cytokines would  differ between nutritional conditions, whereas other circulating cytokines  suggested to be involved  in skeletal muscle adaptation would  not respond differently. Our main finding  was that a pre-exercise meal in general did not influence plasma cytokine responses in the post-resistance exercise period. Findings of chapter 3 and 4 contribute to the view that carbohydrate availability during resistance exercise is of minor importance when aiming for an acute positive skeletal muscle adaptive response. In addition, our data question the importance of carbohydrates as both substrate for resistance exercise and as modulator of the skeletal muscle response that underlies adaptation. Yet, at present it might be premature to change carbohydrate recommendations for individuals performing resistance exercise. Shifting our focus to proteins, we first reviewed the effects and possible underlying physiological mechanisms of protein supplementation on the adaptive response to endurance training in Chapter 5. To further explore these insights, we performed a double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures to determine whether protein supplementation impacts the adaptive response to endurance training. In chapter 6 we provide  proof-of-concept that protein supplementation elicited greater increases in VO2max and stimulated lean mass gain in response to prolonged endurance training. To our knowledge, this was the first double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures showing that protein supplementation enhances the adaptive response to endurance training. These remarkable effects of protein on VO2max that were observed give rise to questions regarding their underlying mechanisms. To this end, we analysed the muscle transcriptome to gain insight into changes in the steady-state gene expression. In chapter 7, we demonstrated that prolonged endurance training changed expression of genes involved in extracellular matrix organisation, energy metabolism and oxidative phosphorylation. Changes in extracellular matrix organisation tended to be greater in the protein group than in the control group and these greater transcriptional changes may reflect the enhanced physiological adaptation as a result of protein supplementation.

AB - Skeletal muscle responds to exercise by a diversity of processes that collectively contribute to short-term and structural adaptations to the demanded performance capacities. There is common consensus that, in general, adequate nutrient availability during and after exercise is important to maximise skeletal muscle adaptation and ultimately performance. At the same time, several knowledge gaps remain regarding the precise mechanisms underlying these effects on adaptation, the most optimal nutrient composition in relation to type of exercise, optimal timing etc.   This dissertation addresses some of these unsolved issues by studying the role of carbohydrates and proteins during adaptation following different forms of exercise. The first part (chapters 2 – 4) focusses on carbohydrate availability with resistance exercise, whereas the second part (chapters 5 - 7) specifically addresses the effects and potential of protein supplementation with endurance training. In chapter 2 we reviewed the existing literature regarding the role of skeletal muscle glycogen with endurance and resistance exercise. Based on this review we concluded that the role of muscle glycogen levels and/or carbohydrate availability on the skeletal muscle adaptive response to resistance exercise requires further scientific attention. To experimentally explore this, we assessed the impact of a pre-exercise meal that differed in macronutrient content on skeletal muscle glycogen levels and acute transcriptional level analysing specific mRNAs in the post-resistance exercise period in chapter 3. Specifically, after a glycogen depleting endurance exercise session in the morning, subjects received an isocaloric mixed meal containing different amounts of carbohydrates and fat 2 hours before a resistance exercise session in the afternoon, while ample protein was provided throughout the day. We hypothesized that some of the selected mRNAs associated with substrate metabolism and mitochondrial biogenesis would differ between the nutritional conditions, without any changes in proteolytic genes. The findings described in  chapter 3 demonstrated that muscle mRNA responses related to exercise adaptation were minimally affected by the pre-exercise meals that differed in macronutrient composition. In chapter 4, derived from the same study, we describe the analysis of a number of plasma cytokine patterns during the day to investigate  whether these mediators were affected by carbohydrate availability. We hypothesized that some selected cytokines would  differ between nutritional conditions, whereas other circulating cytokines  suggested to be involved  in skeletal muscle adaptation would  not respond differently. Our main finding  was that a pre-exercise meal in general did not influence plasma cytokine responses in the post-resistance exercise period. Findings of chapter 3 and 4 contribute to the view that carbohydrate availability during resistance exercise is of minor importance when aiming for an acute positive skeletal muscle adaptive response. In addition, our data question the importance of carbohydrates as both substrate for resistance exercise and as modulator of the skeletal muscle response that underlies adaptation. Yet, at present it might be premature to change carbohydrate recommendations for individuals performing resistance exercise. Shifting our focus to proteins, we first reviewed the effects and possible underlying physiological mechanisms of protein supplementation on the adaptive response to endurance training in Chapter 5. To further explore these insights, we performed a double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures to determine whether protein supplementation impacts the adaptive response to endurance training. In chapter 6 we provide  proof-of-concept that protein supplementation elicited greater increases in VO2max and stimulated lean mass gain in response to prolonged endurance training. To our knowledge, this was the first double-blind randomised controlled trial with repeated measures showing that protein supplementation enhances the adaptive response to endurance training. These remarkable effects of protein on VO2max that were observed give rise to questions regarding their underlying mechanisms. To this end, we analysed the muscle transcriptome to gain insight into changes in the steady-state gene expression. In chapter 7, we demonstrated that prolonged endurance training changed expression of genes involved in extracellular matrix organisation, energy metabolism and oxidative phosphorylation. Changes in extracellular matrix organisation tended to be greater in the protein group than in the control group and these greater transcriptional changes may reflect the enhanced physiological adaptation as a result of protein supplementation.

U2 - 10.18174/479016

DO - 10.18174/479016

M3 - internal PhD, WU

SN - 9789463950060

PB - Wageningen University

CY - Wageningen

ER -