Nitrogen fixation does not axiomatically lead to phosphorus limitation in aquatic ecosystems

Luuk P.A. van Gerven, Jan J. Kuiper*, Wolf M. Mooij, Jan H. Janse, Hans W. Paerl, Jeroen J.M. de Klein

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

A long-standing debate in ecology deals with the role of nitrogen and phosphorus in management and restoration of aquatic ecosystems. It has been argued that nutrient reduction strategies to combat blooms of phytoplankton or floating plants should solely focus on phosphorus (P). The underlying argument is that reducing nitrogen (N) inputs is ineffective because N2-fixing species will compensate for N deficits, thus perpetuating P limitation of primary production. A mechanistic understanding of this principle is, however, incomplete. Here, we use resource competition theory, a complex dynamic ecosystem model and a 32-year field data set on eutrophic, floating-plant dominated ecosystems to show that the growth of non-N2-fixing species can become N limited under high P and low N inputs, even in the presence of N2 fixing species. N2-fixers typically require higher P concentrations than non-N2-fixers to persist. Hence, the N2 fixers cannot deplete the P concentration enough for the non-N2-fixing community to become P limited because they would be outcompeted. These findings provide a testable mechanistic basis for the need to consider the reduction of both N and P inputs to most effectively restore nutrient over-enriched aquatic ecosystems.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)563-570
JournalOikos
Volume128
Issue number4
Early online date13 Oct 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2019

Fingerprint

nitrogen fixation
aquatic ecosystem
phosphorus
ecosystems
nutrients
nitrogen
algal blooms
primary productivity
ecosystem dynamics
nutrient
resource use
ecology
primary production
algal bloom
phytoplankton
ecosystem
aquatic ecosystems

Keywords

  • eutrophication
  • nitrogen fixation
  • R*

Cite this

@article{55042fd2d3ee42dd9ed50a0aea868616,
title = "Nitrogen fixation does not axiomatically lead to phosphorus limitation in aquatic ecosystems",
abstract = "A long-standing debate in ecology deals with the role of nitrogen and phosphorus in management and restoration of aquatic ecosystems. It has been argued that nutrient reduction strategies to combat blooms of phytoplankton or floating plants should solely focus on phosphorus (P). The underlying argument is that reducing nitrogen (N) inputs is ineffective because N2-fixing species will compensate for N deficits, thus perpetuating P limitation of primary production. A mechanistic understanding of this principle is, however, incomplete. Here, we use resource competition theory, a complex dynamic ecosystem model and a 32-year field data set on eutrophic, floating-plant dominated ecosystems to show that the growth of non-N2-fixing species can become N limited under high P and low N inputs, even in the presence of N2 fixing species. N2-fixers typically require higher P concentrations than non-N2-fixers to persist. Hence, the N2 fixers cannot deplete the P concentration enough for the non-N2-fixing community to become P limited because they would be outcompeted. These findings provide a testable mechanistic basis for the need to consider the reduction of both N and P inputs to most effectively restore nutrient over-enriched aquatic ecosystems.",
keywords = "eutrophication, nitrogen fixation, R*",
author = "{van Gerven}, {Luuk P.A.} and Kuiper, {Jan J.} and Mooij, {Wolf M.} and Janse, {Jan H.} and Paerl, {Hans W.} and {de Klein}, {Jeroen J.M.}",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1111/oik.05246",
language = "English",
volume = "128",
pages = "563--570",
journal = "Oikos",
issn = "0030-1299",
publisher = "Nordic Ecological Society",
number = "4",

}

Nitrogen fixation does not axiomatically lead to phosphorus limitation in aquatic ecosystems. / van Gerven, Luuk P.A.; Kuiper, Jan J.; Mooij, Wolf M.; Janse, Jan H.; Paerl, Hans W.; de Klein, Jeroen J.M.

In: Oikos, Vol. 128, No. 4, 04.2019, p. 563-570.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nitrogen fixation does not axiomatically lead to phosphorus limitation in aquatic ecosystems

AU - van Gerven, Luuk P.A.

AU - Kuiper, Jan J.

AU - Mooij, Wolf M.

AU - Janse, Jan H.

AU - Paerl, Hans W.

AU - de Klein, Jeroen J.M.

PY - 2019/4

Y1 - 2019/4

N2 - A long-standing debate in ecology deals with the role of nitrogen and phosphorus in management and restoration of aquatic ecosystems. It has been argued that nutrient reduction strategies to combat blooms of phytoplankton or floating plants should solely focus on phosphorus (P). The underlying argument is that reducing nitrogen (N) inputs is ineffective because N2-fixing species will compensate for N deficits, thus perpetuating P limitation of primary production. A mechanistic understanding of this principle is, however, incomplete. Here, we use resource competition theory, a complex dynamic ecosystem model and a 32-year field data set on eutrophic, floating-plant dominated ecosystems to show that the growth of non-N2-fixing species can become N limited under high P and low N inputs, even in the presence of N2 fixing species. N2-fixers typically require higher P concentrations than non-N2-fixers to persist. Hence, the N2 fixers cannot deplete the P concentration enough for the non-N2-fixing community to become P limited because they would be outcompeted. These findings provide a testable mechanistic basis for the need to consider the reduction of both N and P inputs to most effectively restore nutrient over-enriched aquatic ecosystems.

AB - A long-standing debate in ecology deals with the role of nitrogen and phosphorus in management and restoration of aquatic ecosystems. It has been argued that nutrient reduction strategies to combat blooms of phytoplankton or floating plants should solely focus on phosphorus (P). The underlying argument is that reducing nitrogen (N) inputs is ineffective because N2-fixing species will compensate for N deficits, thus perpetuating P limitation of primary production. A mechanistic understanding of this principle is, however, incomplete. Here, we use resource competition theory, a complex dynamic ecosystem model and a 32-year field data set on eutrophic, floating-plant dominated ecosystems to show that the growth of non-N2-fixing species can become N limited under high P and low N inputs, even in the presence of N2 fixing species. N2-fixers typically require higher P concentrations than non-N2-fixers to persist. Hence, the N2 fixers cannot deplete the P concentration enough for the non-N2-fixing community to become P limited because they would be outcompeted. These findings provide a testable mechanistic basis for the need to consider the reduction of both N and P inputs to most effectively restore nutrient over-enriched aquatic ecosystems.

KW - eutrophication

KW - nitrogen fixation

KW - R

U2 - 10.1111/oik.05246

DO - 10.1111/oik.05246

M3 - Article

VL - 128

SP - 563

EP - 570

JO - Oikos

JF - Oikos

SN - 0030-1299

IS - 4

ER -