Legal Pluralism and the Politics of Inclusion: Recognition and Contestation of Local Water Rights in the Andes

R.A. Boelens, R.R. Bustamente, H. de Vos

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterAcademicpeer-review

    14 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    In the Andean countries water has become a source of intense conflicts. Powerful water-interest groups intervene in local water systems and claim a substantive share of existing water rights, neglecting local agreements. These groups are often supported by neo-liberal water reform and privatization policies. This has led to peasant and indigenous mobilization and community action, grounded in shared rules and collective rights. Attempts to formally recognize local rights systems, however, have not guaranteed concrete protection in day-to-day realities, and the 'politics of recognition' have proved problematic. Legal and policy strategies that simply aim to 'include' local and indigenous rights systems - as 'distinct sets of rules and rights' - in the national frameworks are bound to fail. This chapter outlines some important conclusions of the Latin American WALIR (Water Law and Indigenous Rights Program) and critically examines the false policy dilemma of 'incorporation versus autonomy'. It concludes that the rightful critique to prevailing ethnocentric and universalistic approaches must not lead to equally simplistic praise for local autonomy or to cultural relativist reification of local rights systems. Critical analysis of the power relations that underpin both customary and official rights systems is crucial in order to improve local, national - as well as international - water laws. Local water rights and identities are given shape not by isolation or policies that reduce them to folkloric practices, or by legal and hierarchical subordination, but by conscious confrontation and meaningful communication among plural legal systems.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationCommunity-based Water Law and Water Resource Management Reform in Developing Countries
    EditorsB. van Koppen, M. Giordano, J. Butterworth
    Place of PublicationOxfordshire
    PublisherCABI
    Chapter6
    Pages96-113
    ISBN (Print)9781845933265
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2007

    Publication series

    NameComprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture Series
    PublisherCABI
    Number5

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Legal Pluralism and the Politics of Inclusion: Recognition and Contestation of Local Water Rights in the Andes'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this