Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza

Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference paperAcademic

Abstract

The new EU Animal Health Strategy suggests a shift in emphasis away from control towards prevention and surveillance activities for the management of threats to animal health. The optimal combination of these actions will differ among diseases and depend on largely unknown and uncertain costs and benefits. This paper reports an empirical investigation of this issue for the case of Avian Influenza. The results suggest that the optimal combination of actions will be dependent on the objective of the decision maker and that conflict exists between an optimal strategy which minimises costs to the government and one which maximises producer profits or minimises negative effects on human health. From the perspective of minimising the effects on human health, prevention appears preferable to cure but the case is less clear for other objectives.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 2008
Event12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies - Ghent
Duration: 26 Aug 200829 Aug 2008

Conference

Conference12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies
CityGhent
Period26/08/0829/08/08

Fingerprint

Animals
Influenza
Human health
Empirical investigation
Health
Profit
Optimal strategy
Decision maker
Surveillance
Threat
Costs and benefits
Costs
Government

Cite this

Longworth, N. J., Jongeneel, R., Saatkamp, H. W., & Huirne, R. (2008). Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza. Paper presented at 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies, Ghent, .
Longworth, N.J. ; Jongeneel, R. ; Saatkamp, H.W. ; Huirne, R. / Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza. Paper presented at 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies, Ghent, .
@conference{db5176fa809844bb901b85a3849b65a2,
title = "Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza",
abstract = "The new EU Animal Health Strategy suggests a shift in emphasis away from control towards prevention and surveillance activities for the management of threats to animal health. The optimal combination of these actions will differ among diseases and depend on largely unknown and uncertain costs and benefits. This paper reports an empirical investigation of this issue for the case of Avian Influenza. The results suggest that the optimal combination of actions will be dependent on the objective of the decision maker and that conflict exists between an optimal strategy which minimises costs to the government and one which maximises producer profits or minimises negative effects on human health. From the perspective of minimising the effects on human health, prevention appears preferable to cure but the case is less clear for other objectives.",
author = "N.J. Longworth and R. Jongeneel and H.W. Saatkamp and R. Huirne",
note = "PORmapnr. 1838; 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies ; Conference date: 26-08-2008 Through 29-08-2008",
year = "2008",
language = "English",

}

Longworth, NJ, Jongeneel, R, Saatkamp, HW & Huirne, R 2008, 'Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza' Paper presented at 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies, Ghent, 26/08/08 - 29/08/08, .

Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza. / Longworth, N.J.; Jongeneel, R.; Saatkamp, H.W.; Huirne, R.

2008. Paper presented at 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies, Ghent, .

Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference paperAcademic

TY - CONF

T1 - Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza

AU - Longworth, N.J.

AU - Jongeneel, R.

AU - Saatkamp, H.W.

AU - Huirne, R.

N1 - PORmapnr. 1838

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - The new EU Animal Health Strategy suggests a shift in emphasis away from control towards prevention and surveillance activities for the management of threats to animal health. The optimal combination of these actions will differ among diseases and depend on largely unknown and uncertain costs and benefits. This paper reports an empirical investigation of this issue for the case of Avian Influenza. The results suggest that the optimal combination of actions will be dependent on the objective of the decision maker and that conflict exists between an optimal strategy which minimises costs to the government and one which maximises producer profits or minimises negative effects on human health. From the perspective of minimising the effects on human health, prevention appears preferable to cure but the case is less clear for other objectives.

AB - The new EU Animal Health Strategy suggests a shift in emphasis away from control towards prevention and surveillance activities for the management of threats to animal health. The optimal combination of these actions will differ among diseases and depend on largely unknown and uncertain costs and benefits. This paper reports an empirical investigation of this issue for the case of Avian Influenza. The results suggest that the optimal combination of actions will be dependent on the objective of the decision maker and that conflict exists between an optimal strategy which minimises costs to the government and one which maximises producer profits or minimises negative effects on human health. From the perspective of minimising the effects on human health, prevention appears preferable to cure but the case is less clear for other objectives.

M3 - Conference paper

ER -

Longworth NJ, Jongeneel R, Saatkamp HW, Huirne R. Is prevention better than cure? An empirical investigation for the case of avian influenza. 2008. Paper presented at 12th EAAE Congress: People, Food and Environments: Global Trends and European Strategies, Ghent, .