Integrating collaborative research in marine science: Recommendations from an evaluation of evolving science‐industry partnerships in Dutch demersal fisheries

Nathalie A. Steins*, Marloes L. Kraan, Karin J. van der Reijden, Floor J. Quirijns, Wouter Broekhoven, Jan Jaap Poos

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

The increasingly complex nature of marine resource management calls for stronger stakeholder participation in advancing knowledge and developing management approaches. Studies on stakeholder involvement in marine resource management have primarily focussed on participation in resource use negotiation and not on participation in science. Using fishers' knowledge research frameworks, we evaluate over 15 years of science-industry research collaboration (SIRC) in Dutch demersal fisheries. Four key lessons emerge: (a) Capacity building in SIRC works multiple ways and triggers shifts in the fishers' knowledge research spectrum; (b) Successful SIRC depends on acceptance of industry collected data for scientific advice, which necessitates close involvement of end-users from the outset to provide feedback and obtain
support; (c) (Fisher) participation raises often-overlooked equity questions and may result in selection bias; and (d) The governance context strongly influences structure of SIRC and integration of SIRC knowledge. To ensure a sustainable, continuous process of stakeholder participation and use of their knowledge in marine resources research, collaborative research should be embedded in the institutional frameworks for science and management. It demands continuous maintenance of the relationship between scientists and stakeholders in the context of management developments, calls for reflection about selection and equity considerations, and requires continuous attention for communication with all parties involved at different levels. The lessons learnt in science-industry research collaboration in fisheries are also relevant for the wider field of marine science, where stakeholder participation is necessary but not yet common.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)146-161
Number of pages16
JournalFish and Fisheries
Volume21
Issue number1
Early online date13 Nov 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2020

Fingerprint

demersal fishery
cooperative research
marine science
fisheries
stakeholders
industry
stakeholder
marine resources
marine resource
natural resource management
equity
resource management
recommendation
evaluation
science
institutional framework
capacity building
research work
governance
communication (human)

Keywords

  • collaborative research
  • fishers' knowledge research
  • knowledge co-creation
  • marine resource management
  • marine science
  • Stakeholder participation

Cite this

@article{77f4b2ecb6e24b6698dd9f701abb0534,
title = "Integrating collaborative research in marine science: Recommendations from an evaluation of evolving science‐industry partnerships in Dutch demersal fisheries",
abstract = "The increasingly complex nature of marine resource management calls for stronger stakeholder participation in advancing knowledge and developing management approaches. Studies on stakeholder involvement in marine resource management have primarily focussed on participation in resource use negotiation and not on participation in science. Using fishers' knowledge research frameworks, we evaluate over 15 years of science-industry research collaboration (SIRC) in Dutch demersal fisheries. Four key lessons emerge: (a) Capacity building in SIRC works multiple ways and triggers shifts in the fishers' knowledge research spectrum; (b) Successful SIRC depends on acceptance of industry collected data for scientific advice, which necessitates close involvement of end-users from the outset to provide feedback and obtainsupport; (c) (Fisher) participation raises often-overlooked equity questions and may result in selection bias; and (d) The governance context strongly influences structure of SIRC and integration of SIRC knowledge. To ensure a sustainable, continuous process of stakeholder participation and use of their knowledge in marine resources research, collaborative research should be embedded in the institutional frameworks for science and management. It demands continuous maintenance of the relationship between scientists and stakeholders in the context of management developments, calls for reflection about selection and equity considerations, and requires continuous attention for communication with all parties involved at different levels. The lessons learnt in science-industry research collaboration in fisheries are also relevant for the wider field of marine science, where stakeholder participation is necessary but not yet common.",
keywords = "collaborative research, fishers' knowledge research, knowledge co-creation, marine resource management, marine science, Stakeholder participation",
author = "Steins, {Nathalie A.} and Kraan, {Marloes L.} and {van der Reijden}, {Karin J.} and Quirijns, {Floor J.} and Wouter Broekhoven and Poos, {Jan Jaap}",
year = "2020",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1111/faf.12423",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "146--161",
journal = "Fish and Fisheries",
issn = "1467-2960",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "1",

}

Integrating collaborative research in marine science: Recommendations from an evaluation of evolving science‐industry partnerships in Dutch demersal fisheries. / Steins, Nathalie A.; Kraan, Marloes L.; van der Reijden, Karin J.; Quirijns, Floor J.; Broekhoven, Wouter; Poos, Jan Jaap.

In: Fish and Fisheries, Vol. 21, No. 1, 01.2020, p. 146-161.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Integrating collaborative research in marine science: Recommendations from an evaluation of evolving science‐industry partnerships in Dutch demersal fisheries

AU - Steins, Nathalie A.

AU - Kraan, Marloes L.

AU - van der Reijden, Karin J.

AU - Quirijns, Floor J.

AU - Broekhoven, Wouter

AU - Poos, Jan Jaap

PY - 2020/1

Y1 - 2020/1

N2 - The increasingly complex nature of marine resource management calls for stronger stakeholder participation in advancing knowledge and developing management approaches. Studies on stakeholder involvement in marine resource management have primarily focussed on participation in resource use negotiation and not on participation in science. Using fishers' knowledge research frameworks, we evaluate over 15 years of science-industry research collaboration (SIRC) in Dutch demersal fisheries. Four key lessons emerge: (a) Capacity building in SIRC works multiple ways and triggers shifts in the fishers' knowledge research spectrum; (b) Successful SIRC depends on acceptance of industry collected data for scientific advice, which necessitates close involvement of end-users from the outset to provide feedback and obtainsupport; (c) (Fisher) participation raises often-overlooked equity questions and may result in selection bias; and (d) The governance context strongly influences structure of SIRC and integration of SIRC knowledge. To ensure a sustainable, continuous process of stakeholder participation and use of their knowledge in marine resources research, collaborative research should be embedded in the institutional frameworks for science and management. It demands continuous maintenance of the relationship between scientists and stakeholders in the context of management developments, calls for reflection about selection and equity considerations, and requires continuous attention for communication with all parties involved at different levels. The lessons learnt in science-industry research collaboration in fisheries are also relevant for the wider field of marine science, where stakeholder participation is necessary but not yet common.

AB - The increasingly complex nature of marine resource management calls for stronger stakeholder participation in advancing knowledge and developing management approaches. Studies on stakeholder involvement in marine resource management have primarily focussed on participation in resource use negotiation and not on participation in science. Using fishers' knowledge research frameworks, we evaluate over 15 years of science-industry research collaboration (SIRC) in Dutch demersal fisheries. Four key lessons emerge: (a) Capacity building in SIRC works multiple ways and triggers shifts in the fishers' knowledge research spectrum; (b) Successful SIRC depends on acceptance of industry collected data for scientific advice, which necessitates close involvement of end-users from the outset to provide feedback and obtainsupport; (c) (Fisher) participation raises often-overlooked equity questions and may result in selection bias; and (d) The governance context strongly influences structure of SIRC and integration of SIRC knowledge. To ensure a sustainable, continuous process of stakeholder participation and use of their knowledge in marine resources research, collaborative research should be embedded in the institutional frameworks for science and management. It demands continuous maintenance of the relationship between scientists and stakeholders in the context of management developments, calls for reflection about selection and equity considerations, and requires continuous attention for communication with all parties involved at different levels. The lessons learnt in science-industry research collaboration in fisheries are also relevant for the wider field of marine science, where stakeholder participation is necessary but not yet common.

KW - collaborative research

KW - fishers' knowledge research

KW - knowledge co-creation

KW - marine resource management

KW - marine science

KW - Stakeholder participation

U2 - 10.1111/faf.12423

DO - 10.1111/faf.12423

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 146

EP - 161

JO - Fish and Fisheries

JF - Fish and Fisheries

SN - 1467-2960

IS - 1

ER -