Impact of low denudation rates on soil chemical weathering intensity: A multiproxy approach

Quantifying the influence of denudation, i.e., physical erosion and chemical weathering, on soil weathering intensity is an important component for a comprehensive understanding of element biogeochemical cycles. The relation between the weathering intensity and the denudation rate is not clear and requires further investigation in a variety of climatic and erosional settings. Here, in the Betic Cordillera (southern Spain), we assess the soil chemical weathering intensity with a multiproxy approach combining different indicators of chemical weathering of the soil: the Total Reserve in Bases (TRB), the content in Fe-oxides, the quartz and clay content, the soil cation exchange capacity (CEC), and the silicon (Si) isotope composition of the clay-sized fraction. Our multiproxy approach demonstrates that in this semi-arid environment at low denudation rates, an increasing denudation rate decreases the soil weathering intensity, whereas Si mobility remains limited. Our results converge with previous conclusions based on chemical mass balance methods in the same geological setting. Mass balance methods, and particularly Chemical Depletion Fractions (CDF), are based on the immobility of a refractory element (commonly zirconium, Zr) relative to major cations in soils. Interestingly, our study suggests that a weathering index such as the TRB may provide a useful complement to assess soil chemical weathering intensity in eroding landscapes where the application of chemical mass balances may be hampered by potential Zr mobility in the soil or by heterogeneity of Zr concentrations in the bedrock.