Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis

Francesca Bampa, Lilian O'Sullivan, Kirsten Madena, Taru Sandén, Heide Spiegel, Christian Bugge Henriksen, Bhim Bahadur Ghaley, Arwyn Jones, Jan Staes, Sylvain Sturel, Aneta Trajanov, Rachel E. Creamer, Marko Debeljak

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Soil and its ecosystem functions play a societal role in securing sustainable food production while safeguarding natural resources. A functional land management framework has been proposed to optimize the agro-environmental outputs from the land and specifically the supply and demand of soil functions such as (a) primary productivity, (b) carbon sequestration, (c) water purification and regulation, (d) biodiversity and (e) nutrient cycling, for which soil knowledge is essential. From the outset, the LANDMARK multi-actor research project integrates harvested knowledge from local, national and European stakeholders to develop such guidelines, creating a sense of ownership, trust and reciprocity of the outcomes. About 470 stakeholders from five European countries participated in 32 structured workshops covering multiple land uses in six climatic zones. The harmonized results include stakeholders’ priorities and concerns, perceptions on soil quality and functions, implementation of tools, management techniques, indicators and monitoring, activities and policies, knowledge gaps and ideas. Multi-criteria decision analysis was used for data analysis. Two qualitative models were developed using Decision EXpert methodology to evaluate “knowledge” and “needs”. Soil quality perceptions differed across workshops, depending on the stakeholder level and regionally established terminologies. Stakeholders had good inherent knowledge about soil functioning, but several gaps were identified. In terms of critical requirements, stakeholders defined high technical, activity and policy needs in (a) financial incentives, (b) credible information on improving more sustainable management practices, (c) locally relevant advice, (d) farmers’ discussion groups, (e) training programmes, (f) funding for applied research and monitoring, and (g) strengthening soil science in education.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)6-20
Number of pages15
JournalSoil Use and Management
Volume35
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2019

Fingerprint

multi-criteria decision making
decision analysis
Decision theory
land management
stakeholders
stakeholder
Soils
soil
soil quality
multiple land use
water purification
science education
economic incentives
reciprocity
monitoring
supply balance
soil science
terminology
ownership
ecosystem function

Keywords

  • DEX model
  • farmers and multi-stakeholders
  • locally relevant advice
  • participatory research
  • soil quality

Cite this

Bampa, Francesca ; O'Sullivan, Lilian ; Madena, Kirsten ; Sandén, Taru ; Spiegel, Heide ; Henriksen, Christian Bugge ; Ghaley, Bhim Bahadur ; Jones, Arwyn ; Staes, Jan ; Sturel, Sylvain ; Trajanov, Aneta ; Creamer, Rachel E. ; Debeljak, Marko. / Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis. In: Soil Use and Management. 2019 ; Vol. 35, No. 1. pp. 6-20.
@article{2ee5a7790d4047fea4ce50858b49449d,
title = "Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis",
abstract = "Soil and its ecosystem functions play a societal role in securing sustainable food production while safeguarding natural resources. A functional land management framework has been proposed to optimize the agro-environmental outputs from the land and specifically the supply and demand of soil functions such as (a) primary productivity, (b) carbon sequestration, (c) water purification and regulation, (d) biodiversity and (e) nutrient cycling, for which soil knowledge is essential. From the outset, the LANDMARK multi-actor research project integrates harvested knowledge from local, national and European stakeholders to develop such guidelines, creating a sense of ownership, trust and reciprocity of the outcomes. About 470 stakeholders from five European countries participated in 32 structured workshops covering multiple land uses in six climatic zones. The harmonized results include stakeholders’ priorities and concerns, perceptions on soil quality and functions, implementation of tools, management techniques, indicators and monitoring, activities and policies, knowledge gaps and ideas. Multi-criteria decision analysis was used for data analysis. Two qualitative models were developed using Decision EXpert methodology to evaluate “knowledge” and “needs”. Soil quality perceptions differed across workshops, depending on the stakeholder level and regionally established terminologies. Stakeholders had good inherent knowledge about soil functioning, but several gaps were identified. In terms of critical requirements, stakeholders defined high technical, activity and policy needs in (a) financial incentives, (b) credible information on improving more sustainable management practices, (c) locally relevant advice, (d) farmers’ discussion groups, (e) training programmes, (f) funding for applied research and monitoring, and (g) strengthening soil science in education.",
keywords = "DEX model, farmers and multi-stakeholders, locally relevant advice, participatory research, soil quality",
author = "Francesca Bampa and Lilian O'Sullivan and Kirsten Madena and Taru Sand{\'e}n and Heide Spiegel and Henriksen, {Christian Bugge} and Ghaley, {Bhim Bahadur} and Arwyn Jones and Jan Staes and Sylvain Sturel and Aneta Trajanov and Creamer, {Rachel E.} and Marko Debeljak",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/sum.12506",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "6--20",
journal = "Soil Use and Management",
issn = "0266-0032",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "1",

}

Bampa, F, O'Sullivan, L, Madena, K, Sandén, T, Spiegel, H, Henriksen, CB, Ghaley, BB, Jones, A, Staes, J, Sturel, S, Trajanov, A, Creamer, RE & Debeljak, M 2019, 'Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis' Soil Use and Management, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 6-20. https://doi.org/10.1111/sum.12506

Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis. / Bampa, Francesca; O'Sullivan, Lilian; Madena, Kirsten; Sandén, Taru; Spiegel, Heide; Henriksen, Christian Bugge; Ghaley, Bhim Bahadur; Jones, Arwyn; Staes, Jan; Sturel, Sylvain; Trajanov, Aneta; Creamer, Rachel E.; Debeljak, Marko.

In: Soil Use and Management, Vol. 35, No. 1, 01.03.2019, p. 6-20.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Harvesting European knowledge on soil functions and land management using multi-criteria decision analysis

AU - Bampa, Francesca

AU - O'Sullivan, Lilian

AU - Madena, Kirsten

AU - Sandén, Taru

AU - Spiegel, Heide

AU - Henriksen, Christian Bugge

AU - Ghaley, Bhim Bahadur

AU - Jones, Arwyn

AU - Staes, Jan

AU - Sturel, Sylvain

AU - Trajanov, Aneta

AU - Creamer, Rachel E.

AU - Debeljak, Marko

PY - 2019/3/1

Y1 - 2019/3/1

N2 - Soil and its ecosystem functions play a societal role in securing sustainable food production while safeguarding natural resources. A functional land management framework has been proposed to optimize the agro-environmental outputs from the land and specifically the supply and demand of soil functions such as (a) primary productivity, (b) carbon sequestration, (c) water purification and regulation, (d) biodiversity and (e) nutrient cycling, for which soil knowledge is essential. From the outset, the LANDMARK multi-actor research project integrates harvested knowledge from local, national and European stakeholders to develop such guidelines, creating a sense of ownership, trust and reciprocity of the outcomes. About 470 stakeholders from five European countries participated in 32 structured workshops covering multiple land uses in six climatic zones. The harmonized results include stakeholders’ priorities and concerns, perceptions on soil quality and functions, implementation of tools, management techniques, indicators and monitoring, activities and policies, knowledge gaps and ideas. Multi-criteria decision analysis was used for data analysis. Two qualitative models were developed using Decision EXpert methodology to evaluate “knowledge” and “needs”. Soil quality perceptions differed across workshops, depending on the stakeholder level and regionally established terminologies. Stakeholders had good inherent knowledge about soil functioning, but several gaps were identified. In terms of critical requirements, stakeholders defined high technical, activity and policy needs in (a) financial incentives, (b) credible information on improving more sustainable management practices, (c) locally relevant advice, (d) farmers’ discussion groups, (e) training programmes, (f) funding for applied research and monitoring, and (g) strengthening soil science in education.

AB - Soil and its ecosystem functions play a societal role in securing sustainable food production while safeguarding natural resources. A functional land management framework has been proposed to optimize the agro-environmental outputs from the land and specifically the supply and demand of soil functions such as (a) primary productivity, (b) carbon sequestration, (c) water purification and regulation, (d) biodiversity and (e) nutrient cycling, for which soil knowledge is essential. From the outset, the LANDMARK multi-actor research project integrates harvested knowledge from local, national and European stakeholders to develop such guidelines, creating a sense of ownership, trust and reciprocity of the outcomes. About 470 stakeholders from five European countries participated in 32 structured workshops covering multiple land uses in six climatic zones. The harmonized results include stakeholders’ priorities and concerns, perceptions on soil quality and functions, implementation of tools, management techniques, indicators and monitoring, activities and policies, knowledge gaps and ideas. Multi-criteria decision analysis was used for data analysis. Two qualitative models were developed using Decision EXpert methodology to evaluate “knowledge” and “needs”. Soil quality perceptions differed across workshops, depending on the stakeholder level and regionally established terminologies. Stakeholders had good inherent knowledge about soil functioning, but several gaps were identified. In terms of critical requirements, stakeholders defined high technical, activity and policy needs in (a) financial incentives, (b) credible information on improving more sustainable management practices, (c) locally relevant advice, (d) farmers’ discussion groups, (e) training programmes, (f) funding for applied research and monitoring, and (g) strengthening soil science in education.

KW - DEX model

KW - farmers and multi-stakeholders

KW - locally relevant advice

KW - participatory research

KW - soil quality

U2 - 10.1111/sum.12506

DO - 10.1111/sum.12506

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 6

EP - 20

JO - Soil Use and Management

JF - Soil Use and Management

SN - 0266-0032

IS - 1

ER -