Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

For an analytics of affective life: marginalized youths, social interventions and development affectspheres in Cusco, Peru

Research output: Thesis › internal PhD, WU

Abstract

In this thesis, I use the term “alternative interventions” to address specific non-state-led and multi-faceted welfare and inclusion operations in Cusco, Peru, that intervene in situations of precarity and vulnerability through promoting young people’s long-term well-being, development and livelihoods. These “alternative” interventions are small-scale and locally based even as they draw on resources internationally and involve non-local actors. Instead of examining large-scale, Peruvian state-led programmes, or voices of dissent towards those programmes, my thesis aims to understand groups of vulnerable and marginalized people’s experiences of the “alternative interventions” set up relative to them. My thesis draws on the literature on affect and embodiment in and beyond human geography in order to develop a set of analytics—i.e., tools, strategies or ways of doing analysis and the underlying rationale—for studying young people’s lived and affective experiences of two non-governmental social and residential care centres in Cusco, Peru.

Chapter 1 provides an overview of critical scholarly literatures on the welfare of marginalized young populations in Peru. In this chapter, I contend that it is both scholarly and societally relevant to produce—besides critiques of the state power and structural conditions impacting the population—knowledge about any existing “alternative” interventions and modes of social organization that support or facilitate changes in the welfare of vulnerable and marginalized groups. Chapter 2 develops a robust approach to examining the lived and affective experiences of marginalized youths faced with interventions through critically reviewing literatures on children’s and youth geographies and on the geographies of development volunteering. I identify the theoretical and analytical issues at stake in using insights from these literatures for the purpose of my thesis research. I then introduce Berlant’s (2011) affect theory and develop a Berlant-inspired analytics of “affective life” that allows me to address the limitations in geographers’ discussions on young people’s lives and welfare and on social organization and development interventions influencing their welfare.

In Chapter 3, I construct a methodology inspired by a variety of methodological discussions across geographical, anthropological, feminist, and childhood and youth research. Drawing on these methodological discussions, I detail the practical, methodological and ethical considerations involved in my seven-month-long ethnographic study of the affective life at two non-governmental social and residential care centres, Runachay and CARA, in Cusco, Peru. The chapter also presents my multi-method approach to Runachay and CARA resident-beneficiaries’ “expressions” during the fieldwork and my positionality working with the young participants.

Chapter 4 seeks to understand the operations of Runachay’s politics of childhood/youth through social and vocational education in light of other existing structural forces and forms of power influencing the lives of these young people in Cusco’s social contexts. This chapter looks at the nuanced ways in which Runachay’s resident-beneficiaries individually and collectively feel about, make sense of and respond to Runachay’s facilitation of their well-being and their aspirations. In so doing, the chapter analyzes how Runachay mediates the precarity in Cusco’s urban economies faced by the girls in their rural-to-urban migration. It shows how the centre intervenes in the ordinary conditions in Cusco, and in Peru more generally, that shape Quechua-speaking girls’ domestic labour, their schooling and future employment. The analysis in this chapter critically unpacks the “alternative” workings of Runachay’s interventions, which are grounded in and materialized through the quotidian.

Chapter 5 performs critiques of affect-inflected literature in the geographies of development and volunteering. This chapter argues for development geographers to pay attention to the affective life—the feelings, desires, affective states and capacities that emerge among the populations relying on development aid who are often represented as “poor” or “vulnerable” in public discourses and in writings on development volunteering. This chapter examines the “affective life” at CARA, a popular destination in Cusco for international volunteering. CARA has as its principal function the provision of residential care to adolescent mothers who are either survivors of rape or sexual abuse, or who lack family and community support for managing early pregnancy and motherhood. The chapter considers how the residents rely on CARA’s institutional-collective arrangements as they respond to socio-politically shaped vulnerability in everyday or long-term modes of living. In light of CARA’s collective household environment and the sensibilities it promotes among its residents, the chapter shows that the involvement of international volunteers affects residents’ capacities for living on and (self-)transformation in complex and sometimes problematic ways.

Chapter 6 provides a review of the discussions emerging from the preceding chapters. Based on this review, I highlight my thesis’s contribution not only to the scholarly discussion on social and educational interventions in young people’s lives but also to literatures on the geographies of children and youth more generally. I also reflect on my intervention in the “affect turn” of the geographies of development volunteering and volunteer tourism. Chapter 6 then reflects on the implications of Berlantian deep ethnography for social and development policy critique and advocacy. I conclude my thesis in Chapter 6 by laying out aspects of the Cusco cases for further research as well as by formulating other conceptual and theoretical issues worth exploring using the Berlantian framework developed in my thesis.

Original languageEnglish
QualificationDoctor of Philosophy
Awarding Institution
  • Wageningen University
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Minca, C., Promotor
  • Ormond, Meghann, Co-promotor
Award date8 Sept 2020
Place of PublicationWageningen
Publisher
Print ISBNs9789463954365
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 8 Sept 2020

UN SDGs

This output contributes to the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

  1. SDG 1 - No Poverty
    SDG 1 No Poverty

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'For an analytics of affective life: marginalized youths, social interventions and development affectspheres in Cusco, Peru'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this