Environmental communication in the Information Age: Institutional barriers and opportunities in the provision of river data to the general public

K.A.J. Arts, A.A.R. Ioris, C.J.A. Macleod, X. Han, S.G. Sripada, J.R.Z. Braga, R. van der Wal

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In an era of increased human pressure on planet Earth, sound environmental governance regimes are more important than ever. Digital technologies are increasingly turned to by environmental regulators to aid governance and communication. We examine the ‘behind the scenes’ institutional dynamics of a public body in its digital information provision (specifically dynamic river level information). Based on in-depth interviews with staff across a large environmental regulator we have brought to light four pivotal areas of institutional dynamics: (1) institutional priority and path dependency; (2) management and resources; (3) institutional identity and interdepartmental dynamics; and (4) ability and willingness to change. We gained insight into explicit and covert barriers and opportunities in relation to digital information provision that are likely to occur in other public institutions too. Besides identified barriers that were of a technical, structural, managerial or cultural nature, arguably the most important barrier was conceptual, i.e. the prevalence of ‘efficiency and efficacy’ perspectives on information and communications technology (ICT) amongst staff, in which ICT is primarily perceived as a neutral solution in itself to a wide variety of issues. Opportunities were nonetheless present in the form of enthusiasm and some critical thinking about digital innovation among staff, and an emphasis on the importance of stakeholder inclusion in the design of ICT. We conclude that there is a need to connect institutional social learning with the development of ‘conceptual perspectives’ on ICT, in which ICT is not seen as a solution in itself, but as a set of tools in a wider transformational process, or as a lens to look at existing or new practices. This is more likely to strengthen cornerstones of contemporary environmental governance, such as improved information access and reconceptualisations of ‘traditional’ barriers of uncertainty, liability and distrust in relation to information provision.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)47-53
JournalEnvironmental Science & Policy
Volume55
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

information and communication technology
communication technology
information technology
river
communication
governance
staff
public institution
social learning
liability
aid
stakeholder
innovation
planet
learning
inclusion
public
uncertainty
efficiency
ability

Cite this

Arts, K.A.J. ; Ioris, A.A.R. ; Macleod, C.J.A. ; Han, X. ; Sripada, S.G. ; Braga, J.R.Z. ; van der Wal, R. / Environmental communication in the Information Age: Institutional barriers and opportunities in the provision of river data to the general public. In: Environmental Science & Policy. 2016 ; Vol. 55, No. 1. pp. 47-53.
@article{66e9f13f9a0e48ab83d9ed0626aedf2b,
title = "Environmental communication in the Information Age: Institutional barriers and opportunities in the provision of river data to the general public",
abstract = "In an era of increased human pressure on planet Earth, sound environmental governance regimes are more important than ever. Digital technologies are increasingly turned to by environmental regulators to aid governance and communication. We examine the ‘behind the scenes’ institutional dynamics of a public body in its digital information provision (specifically dynamic river level information). Based on in-depth interviews with staff across a large environmental regulator we have brought to light four pivotal areas of institutional dynamics: (1) institutional priority and path dependency; (2) management and resources; (3) institutional identity and interdepartmental dynamics; and (4) ability and willingness to change. We gained insight into explicit and covert barriers and opportunities in relation to digital information provision that are likely to occur in other public institutions too. Besides identified barriers that were of a technical, structural, managerial or cultural nature, arguably the most important barrier was conceptual, i.e. the prevalence of ‘efficiency and efficacy’ perspectives on information and communications technology (ICT) amongst staff, in which ICT is primarily perceived as a neutral solution in itself to a wide variety of issues. Opportunities were nonetheless present in the form of enthusiasm and some critical thinking about digital innovation among staff, and an emphasis on the importance of stakeholder inclusion in the design of ICT. We conclude that there is a need to connect institutional social learning with the development of ‘conceptual perspectives’ on ICT, in which ICT is not seen as a solution in itself, but as a set of tools in a wider transformational process, or as a lens to look at existing or new practices. This is more likely to strengthen cornerstones of contemporary environmental governance, such as improved information access and reconceptualisations of ‘traditional’ barriers of uncertainty, liability and distrust in relation to information provision.",
author = "K.A.J. Arts and A.A.R. Ioris and C.J.A. Macleod and X. Han and S.G. Sripada and J.R.Z. Braga and {van der Wal}, R.",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1016/j.envsci.2015.08.011",
language = "English",
volume = "55",
pages = "47--53",
journal = "Environmental Science & Policy",
issn = "1462-9011",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1",

}

Environmental communication in the Information Age: Institutional barriers and opportunities in the provision of river data to the general public. / Arts, K.A.J.; Ioris, A.A.R.; Macleod, C.J.A.; Han, X.; Sripada, S.G.; Braga, J.R.Z.; van der Wal, R.

In: Environmental Science & Policy, Vol. 55, No. 1, 2016, p. 47-53.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Environmental communication in the Information Age: Institutional barriers and opportunities in the provision of river data to the general public

AU - Arts, K.A.J.

AU - Ioris, A.A.R.

AU - Macleod, C.J.A.

AU - Han, X.

AU - Sripada, S.G.

AU - Braga, J.R.Z.

AU - van der Wal, R.

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - In an era of increased human pressure on planet Earth, sound environmental governance regimes are more important than ever. Digital technologies are increasingly turned to by environmental regulators to aid governance and communication. We examine the ‘behind the scenes’ institutional dynamics of a public body in its digital information provision (specifically dynamic river level information). Based on in-depth interviews with staff across a large environmental regulator we have brought to light four pivotal areas of institutional dynamics: (1) institutional priority and path dependency; (2) management and resources; (3) institutional identity and interdepartmental dynamics; and (4) ability and willingness to change. We gained insight into explicit and covert barriers and opportunities in relation to digital information provision that are likely to occur in other public institutions too. Besides identified barriers that were of a technical, structural, managerial or cultural nature, arguably the most important barrier was conceptual, i.e. the prevalence of ‘efficiency and efficacy’ perspectives on information and communications technology (ICT) amongst staff, in which ICT is primarily perceived as a neutral solution in itself to a wide variety of issues. Opportunities were nonetheless present in the form of enthusiasm and some critical thinking about digital innovation among staff, and an emphasis on the importance of stakeholder inclusion in the design of ICT. We conclude that there is a need to connect institutional social learning with the development of ‘conceptual perspectives’ on ICT, in which ICT is not seen as a solution in itself, but as a set of tools in a wider transformational process, or as a lens to look at existing or new practices. This is more likely to strengthen cornerstones of contemporary environmental governance, such as improved information access and reconceptualisations of ‘traditional’ barriers of uncertainty, liability and distrust in relation to information provision.

AB - In an era of increased human pressure on planet Earth, sound environmental governance regimes are more important than ever. Digital technologies are increasingly turned to by environmental regulators to aid governance and communication. We examine the ‘behind the scenes’ institutional dynamics of a public body in its digital information provision (specifically dynamic river level information). Based on in-depth interviews with staff across a large environmental regulator we have brought to light four pivotal areas of institutional dynamics: (1) institutional priority and path dependency; (2) management and resources; (3) institutional identity and interdepartmental dynamics; and (4) ability and willingness to change. We gained insight into explicit and covert barriers and opportunities in relation to digital information provision that are likely to occur in other public institutions too. Besides identified barriers that were of a technical, structural, managerial or cultural nature, arguably the most important barrier was conceptual, i.e. the prevalence of ‘efficiency and efficacy’ perspectives on information and communications technology (ICT) amongst staff, in which ICT is primarily perceived as a neutral solution in itself to a wide variety of issues. Opportunities were nonetheless present in the form of enthusiasm and some critical thinking about digital innovation among staff, and an emphasis on the importance of stakeholder inclusion in the design of ICT. We conclude that there is a need to connect institutional social learning with the development of ‘conceptual perspectives’ on ICT, in which ICT is not seen as a solution in itself, but as a set of tools in a wider transformational process, or as a lens to look at existing or new practices. This is more likely to strengthen cornerstones of contemporary environmental governance, such as improved information access and reconceptualisations of ‘traditional’ barriers of uncertainty, liability and distrust in relation to information provision.

U2 - 10.1016/j.envsci.2015.08.011

DO - 10.1016/j.envsci.2015.08.011

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 47

EP - 53

JO - Environmental Science & Policy

JF - Environmental Science & Policy

SN - 1462-9011

IS - 1

ER -