Economic value of management information systems in pig farming

Research output: Thesisinternal PhD, WU

Abstract

<p>The research described in this thesis focused on developing and testing methods to determine the profitability of management information systems (MIS) in livestock farming Methods were first applied to evaluating MIS in pig farming. Economic value of MIS arises from the fact that farmers have limited time, motivation or skills to decide consistently. Therefore, positive research approaches that derive MIS benefits from actual decision making of farmers, such as survey studies and economics experiments, have more potential for MIS evaluation than normative research approaches that assess MIS benefit with predetermined decision criteria, such as decision tree analysis and simulation studies Firstly, a survey study was conducted to evaluate MIS in pig farming. To sort out the effect of "better management" from the actual benefits of MIS, a panel data set was created by combining data of the survey study with data collected on the same farms in 1983. Adjusted for farm, trend, and learning effects, production on farms adopting MIS increase by 0.56 piglets per sow per year (p=0.09). Tests for autocorrelation, influential observations, and nonequivalent control time-series indicated that this outcome is robust Secondly, the impact of farm characteristics on MIS profitability was investigate comparing two conceptually different farm classification methods within the same research population: the sociological "style of farming" approach and the farm-economic "management level" approach. Farmers with high management levels got more added value from MIS. Finally, an individual decision-making experiment was conducted to yield insight into whether laboratory economics experiments can be used as an alternative to surveys for determining the profitability of MIS in sow farming. Instead of linking MIS us to farm results directly, the effect of different information levels on decision making was investigated under controlled laboratory conditions. Many of the farmers in the experiment also participated in the above-mentioned survey study. Although an overall effect of MI was found in both the experiment and the survey study, experimental and survey MI estimates were not significantly correlated. Possible explanations for these uncorrelated estimates are discussed in the thesis.
Original languageEnglish
QualificationDoctor of Philosophy
Awarding Institution
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Renkema, J.A., Promotor
  • Dijkhuizen, A.A., Promotor, External person
  • Huirne, R.B.M., Promotor, External person
Award date18 Feb 1998
Place of PublicationS.l.
Publisher
Print ISBNs9789054858119
Publication statusPublished - 1998

Fingerprint

management information systems
economic valuation
farming systems
swine
farms
profitability
farmers
decision making
economics
sows
farm typology
farm management
value added
autocorrelation

Keywords

  • information systems
  • automation
  • management
  • pigs
  • economics
  • commodities
  • values
  • farm management
  • farm results
  • profitability

Cite this

@phdthesis{0bf399d9ba474539a4fb7cd09f0a8919,
title = "Economic value of management information systems in pig farming",
abstract = "The research described in this thesis focused on developing and testing methods to determine the profitability of management information systems (MIS) in livestock farming Methods were first applied to evaluating MIS in pig farming. Economic value of MIS arises from the fact that farmers have limited time, motivation or skills to decide consistently. Therefore, positive research approaches that derive MIS benefits from actual decision making of farmers, such as survey studies and economics experiments, have more potential for MIS evaluation than normative research approaches that assess MIS benefit with predetermined decision criteria, such as decision tree analysis and simulation studies Firstly, a survey study was conducted to evaluate MIS in pig farming. To sort out the effect of {"}better management{"} from the actual benefits of MIS, a panel data set was created by combining data of the survey study with data collected on the same farms in 1983. Adjusted for farm, trend, and learning effects, production on farms adopting MIS increase by 0.56 piglets per sow per year (p=0.09). Tests for autocorrelation, influential observations, and nonequivalent control time-series indicated that this outcome is robust Secondly, the impact of farm characteristics on MIS profitability was investigate comparing two conceptually different farm classification methods within the same research population: the sociological {"}style of farming{"} approach and the farm-economic {"}management level{"} approach. Farmers with high management levels got more added value from MIS. Finally, an individual decision-making experiment was conducted to yield insight into whether laboratory economics experiments can be used as an alternative to surveys for determining the profitability of MIS in sow farming. Instead of linking MIS us to farm results directly, the effect of different information levels on decision making was investigated under controlled laboratory conditions. Many of the farmers in the experiment also participated in the above-mentioned survey study. Although an overall effect of MI was found in both the experiment and the survey study, experimental and survey MI estimates were not significantly correlated. Possible explanations for these uncorrelated estimates are discussed in the thesis.",
keywords = "informatiesystemen, automatisering, bedrijfsvoering, varkens, economie, basisproducten, waarden, agrarische bedrijfsvoering, bedrijfsresultaten in de landbouw, rentabiliteit, information systems, automation, management, pigs, economics, commodities, values, farm management, farm results, profitability",
author = "J.A.A.M. Verstegen",
note = "WU thesis 2391 Proefschrift Wageningen",
year = "1998",
language = "English",
isbn = "9789054858119",
publisher = "Verstegen",

}

Economic value of management information systems in pig farming. / Verstegen, J.A.A.M.

S.l. : Verstegen, 1998. 113 p.

Research output: Thesisinternal PhD, WU

TY - THES

T1 - Economic value of management information systems in pig farming

AU - Verstegen, J.A.A.M.

N1 - WU thesis 2391 Proefschrift Wageningen

PY - 1998

Y1 - 1998

N2 - The research described in this thesis focused on developing and testing methods to determine the profitability of management information systems (MIS) in livestock farming Methods were first applied to evaluating MIS in pig farming. Economic value of MIS arises from the fact that farmers have limited time, motivation or skills to decide consistently. Therefore, positive research approaches that derive MIS benefits from actual decision making of farmers, such as survey studies and economics experiments, have more potential for MIS evaluation than normative research approaches that assess MIS benefit with predetermined decision criteria, such as decision tree analysis and simulation studies Firstly, a survey study was conducted to evaluate MIS in pig farming. To sort out the effect of "better management" from the actual benefits of MIS, a panel data set was created by combining data of the survey study with data collected on the same farms in 1983. Adjusted for farm, trend, and learning effects, production on farms adopting MIS increase by 0.56 piglets per sow per year (p=0.09). Tests for autocorrelation, influential observations, and nonequivalent control time-series indicated that this outcome is robust Secondly, the impact of farm characteristics on MIS profitability was investigate comparing two conceptually different farm classification methods within the same research population: the sociological "style of farming" approach and the farm-economic "management level" approach. Farmers with high management levels got more added value from MIS. Finally, an individual decision-making experiment was conducted to yield insight into whether laboratory economics experiments can be used as an alternative to surveys for determining the profitability of MIS in sow farming. Instead of linking MIS us to farm results directly, the effect of different information levels on decision making was investigated under controlled laboratory conditions. Many of the farmers in the experiment also participated in the above-mentioned survey study. Although an overall effect of MI was found in both the experiment and the survey study, experimental and survey MI estimates were not significantly correlated. Possible explanations for these uncorrelated estimates are discussed in the thesis.

AB - The research described in this thesis focused on developing and testing methods to determine the profitability of management information systems (MIS) in livestock farming Methods were first applied to evaluating MIS in pig farming. Economic value of MIS arises from the fact that farmers have limited time, motivation or skills to decide consistently. Therefore, positive research approaches that derive MIS benefits from actual decision making of farmers, such as survey studies and economics experiments, have more potential for MIS evaluation than normative research approaches that assess MIS benefit with predetermined decision criteria, such as decision tree analysis and simulation studies Firstly, a survey study was conducted to evaluate MIS in pig farming. To sort out the effect of "better management" from the actual benefits of MIS, a panel data set was created by combining data of the survey study with data collected on the same farms in 1983. Adjusted for farm, trend, and learning effects, production on farms adopting MIS increase by 0.56 piglets per sow per year (p=0.09). Tests for autocorrelation, influential observations, and nonequivalent control time-series indicated that this outcome is robust Secondly, the impact of farm characteristics on MIS profitability was investigate comparing two conceptually different farm classification methods within the same research population: the sociological "style of farming" approach and the farm-economic "management level" approach. Farmers with high management levels got more added value from MIS. Finally, an individual decision-making experiment was conducted to yield insight into whether laboratory economics experiments can be used as an alternative to surveys for determining the profitability of MIS in sow farming. Instead of linking MIS us to farm results directly, the effect of different information levels on decision making was investigated under controlled laboratory conditions. Many of the farmers in the experiment also participated in the above-mentioned survey study. Although an overall effect of MI was found in both the experiment and the survey study, experimental and survey MI estimates were not significantly correlated. Possible explanations for these uncorrelated estimates are discussed in the thesis.

KW - informatiesystemen

KW - automatisering

KW - bedrijfsvoering

KW - varkens

KW - economie

KW - basisproducten

KW - waarden

KW - agrarische bedrijfsvoering

KW - bedrijfsresultaten in de landbouw

KW - rentabiliteit

KW - information systems

KW - automation

KW - management

KW - pigs

KW - economics

KW - commodities

KW - values

KW - farm management

KW - farm results

KW - profitability

M3 - internal PhD, WU

SN - 9789054858119

PB - Verstegen

CY - S.l.

ER -