Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations?

Suzanne T.S. van Beeck Calkoen*, Dries P.J. Kuijper, Håkan Sand, Navinder J. Singh, Sip E. van Wieren, Joris P.G.M. Cromsigt

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Large carnivores can be a key factor in shaping their ungulate prey's behavior, which may affect lower trophic levels. While most studies on trade-offs between food acquisition and risk avoidance by ungulate prey species have been conducted in areas with limited human impact, carnivores are now increasingly returning to highly anthropogenic landscapes. Many of these landscapes are dominated by forestry, and ungulate-forestry conflicts are an increasing issue. The aim of this study was to test if the indirect effects of a re-colonizing large predator, the wolf Canis lupus, results in a change in browsing intensity by moose Alces alces in young forest plantations in a boreal forest in Sweden. We selected 24 different forest plantations, with 12 located in low-wolf and 12 in high-wolf utilization areas. In each plantation, we measured browsing intensity, tree height, tree density, distance to the closest forest edge and we counted the number of moose pellet groups. In contrast to our predictions, wolf utilization was not the main driver of moose browsing patterns. Instead, moose browsing intensity declined with tree density and height. Separate analyses on the main tree species showed that wolf utilization had an influence, but browsing intensity was in fact higher in the high-wolf utilization areas for three out of five tree species. This pattern seemed to be driven by a strong confounding relationship between wolf utilization, tree density and height, which were both lower in the high-wolf utilization areas. We argue that this confounding effect is due to wolves being pushed towards the less productive parts of the landscape away from human activity centers. Therefore, we concluded that in order to better understand carnivore driven risk-mediated effects on herbivore behavior in anthropogenic landscapes we need to better understand the complexity of human-carnivore-prey-ecosystem interactions. Ecography
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1776-1787
JournalEcography
Volume41
Issue number11
Early online date30 Jan 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2018

Fingerprint

Alces alces
forest plantations
browsing
wolves
plantation
carnivore
ungulate
carnivores
ungulates
forestry
anthropogenic activities
forest edge
anthropogenic effect
trophic level
boreal forest
young
herbivore
human activity
Canis lupus
predator

Keywords

  • Anthropogenic landscapes
  • Behaviorally-mediated trophic cascades
  • Wolf-ungulate interactions

Cite this

van Beeck Calkoen, S. T. S., Kuijper, D. P. J., Sand, H., Singh, N. J., van Wieren, S. E., & Cromsigt, J. P. G. M. (2018). Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations? Ecography, 41(11), 1776-1787. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecog.03329
van Beeck Calkoen, Suzanne T.S. ; Kuijper, Dries P.J. ; Sand, Håkan ; Singh, Navinder J. ; van Wieren, Sip E. ; Cromsigt, Joris P.G.M. / Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations?. In: Ecography. 2018 ; Vol. 41, No. 11. pp. 1776-1787.
@article{58fab2f7a9014c40919e584c2d2f47a0,
title = "Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations?",
abstract = "Large carnivores can be a key factor in shaping their ungulate prey's behavior, which may affect lower trophic levels. While most studies on trade-offs between food acquisition and risk avoidance by ungulate prey species have been conducted in areas with limited human impact, carnivores are now increasingly returning to highly anthropogenic landscapes. Many of these landscapes are dominated by forestry, and ungulate-forestry conflicts are an increasing issue. The aim of this study was to test if the indirect effects of a re-colonizing large predator, the wolf Canis lupus, results in a change in browsing intensity by moose Alces alces in young forest plantations in a boreal forest in Sweden. We selected 24 different forest plantations, with 12 located in low-wolf and 12 in high-wolf utilization areas. In each plantation, we measured browsing intensity, tree height, tree density, distance to the closest forest edge and we counted the number of moose pellet groups. In contrast to our predictions, wolf utilization was not the main driver of moose browsing patterns. Instead, moose browsing intensity declined with tree density and height. Separate analyses on the main tree species showed that wolf utilization had an influence, but browsing intensity was in fact higher in the high-wolf utilization areas for three out of five tree species. This pattern seemed to be driven by a strong confounding relationship between wolf utilization, tree density and height, which were both lower in the high-wolf utilization areas. We argue that this confounding effect is due to wolves being pushed towards the less productive parts of the landscape away from human activity centers. Therefore, we concluded that in order to better understand carnivore driven risk-mediated effects on herbivore behavior in anthropogenic landscapes we need to better understand the complexity of human-carnivore-prey-ecosystem interactions. Ecography",
keywords = "Anthropogenic landscapes, Behaviorally-mediated trophic cascades, Wolf-ungulate interactions",
author = "{van Beeck Calkoen}, {Suzanne T.S.} and Kuijper, {Dries P.J.} and H{\aa}kan Sand and Singh, {Navinder J.} and {van Wieren}, {Sip E.} and Cromsigt, {Joris P.G.M.}",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1111/ecog.03329",
language = "English",
volume = "41",
pages = "1776--1787",
journal = "Ecography",
issn = "0906-7590",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "11",

}

van Beeck Calkoen, STS, Kuijper, DPJ, Sand, H, Singh, NJ, van Wieren, SE & Cromsigt, JPGM 2018, 'Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations?', Ecography, vol. 41, no. 11, pp. 1776-1787. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecog.03329

Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations? / van Beeck Calkoen, Suzanne T.S.; Kuijper, Dries P.J.; Sand, Håkan; Singh, Navinder J.; van Wieren, Sip E.; Cromsigt, Joris P.G.M.

In: Ecography, Vol. 41, No. 11, 11.2018, p. 1776-1787.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations?

AU - van Beeck Calkoen, Suzanne T.S.

AU - Kuijper, Dries P.J.

AU - Sand, Håkan

AU - Singh, Navinder J.

AU - van Wieren, Sip E.

AU - Cromsigt, Joris P.G.M.

PY - 2018/11

Y1 - 2018/11

N2 - Large carnivores can be a key factor in shaping their ungulate prey's behavior, which may affect lower trophic levels. While most studies on trade-offs between food acquisition and risk avoidance by ungulate prey species have been conducted in areas with limited human impact, carnivores are now increasingly returning to highly anthropogenic landscapes. Many of these landscapes are dominated by forestry, and ungulate-forestry conflicts are an increasing issue. The aim of this study was to test if the indirect effects of a re-colonizing large predator, the wolf Canis lupus, results in a change in browsing intensity by moose Alces alces in young forest plantations in a boreal forest in Sweden. We selected 24 different forest plantations, with 12 located in low-wolf and 12 in high-wolf utilization areas. In each plantation, we measured browsing intensity, tree height, tree density, distance to the closest forest edge and we counted the number of moose pellet groups. In contrast to our predictions, wolf utilization was not the main driver of moose browsing patterns. Instead, moose browsing intensity declined with tree density and height. Separate analyses on the main tree species showed that wolf utilization had an influence, but browsing intensity was in fact higher in the high-wolf utilization areas for three out of five tree species. This pattern seemed to be driven by a strong confounding relationship between wolf utilization, tree density and height, which were both lower in the high-wolf utilization areas. We argue that this confounding effect is due to wolves being pushed towards the less productive parts of the landscape away from human activity centers. Therefore, we concluded that in order to better understand carnivore driven risk-mediated effects on herbivore behavior in anthropogenic landscapes we need to better understand the complexity of human-carnivore-prey-ecosystem interactions. Ecography

AB - Large carnivores can be a key factor in shaping their ungulate prey's behavior, which may affect lower trophic levels. While most studies on trade-offs between food acquisition and risk avoidance by ungulate prey species have been conducted in areas with limited human impact, carnivores are now increasingly returning to highly anthropogenic landscapes. Many of these landscapes are dominated by forestry, and ungulate-forestry conflicts are an increasing issue. The aim of this study was to test if the indirect effects of a re-colonizing large predator, the wolf Canis lupus, results in a change in browsing intensity by moose Alces alces in young forest plantations in a boreal forest in Sweden. We selected 24 different forest plantations, with 12 located in low-wolf and 12 in high-wolf utilization areas. In each plantation, we measured browsing intensity, tree height, tree density, distance to the closest forest edge and we counted the number of moose pellet groups. In contrast to our predictions, wolf utilization was not the main driver of moose browsing patterns. Instead, moose browsing intensity declined with tree density and height. Separate analyses on the main tree species showed that wolf utilization had an influence, but browsing intensity was in fact higher in the high-wolf utilization areas for three out of five tree species. This pattern seemed to be driven by a strong confounding relationship between wolf utilization, tree density and height, which were both lower in the high-wolf utilization areas. We argue that this confounding effect is due to wolves being pushed towards the less productive parts of the landscape away from human activity centers. Therefore, we concluded that in order to better understand carnivore driven risk-mediated effects on herbivore behavior in anthropogenic landscapes we need to better understand the complexity of human-carnivore-prey-ecosystem interactions. Ecography

KW - Anthropogenic landscapes

KW - Behaviorally-mediated trophic cascades

KW - Wolf-ungulate interactions

U2 - 10.1111/ecog.03329

DO - 10.1111/ecog.03329

M3 - Article

VL - 41

SP - 1776

EP - 1787

JO - Ecography

JF - Ecography

SN - 0906-7590

IS - 11

ER -

van Beeck Calkoen STS, Kuijper DPJ, Sand H, Singh NJ, van Wieren SE, Cromsigt JPGM. Does wolf presence reduce moose browsing intensity in young forest plantations? Ecography. 2018 Nov;41(11):1776-1787. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecog.03329