Brazil Nut Forest Concessions in the Peruvian Amazon: Success or Failure?

H.V. Willem, V.J. Ingram, M.R. Guariguata

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

In Peru, concessions for harvesting Brazil nuts (fruits of the Amazon tree Bertholletia excelsa) were launched in the Madre de Dios Department in 2000. This study analyses the extent to which the Brazil nut concession system (which covers about 1 million ha of closed canopy forest) has met its objective of providing a governance model for sustainable and equitable use. Primary and secondary information sources were used to analyse governance outcomes based on 10 indicators, and the performance of Brazil nut concessions in two contrasting land-use types in Madre de Dios were compared (within and outside protected areas). It was found that corresponding institutional arrangements have led, more than a decade later, to different socioeconomic, ecological and legal outcomes. Particularly outside protected areas, where the vast majority of the concessions are located, a paradoxical situation was found of ineffective over-regulation on paper but minimal intervention from state agencies; ineffective state monitoring and sanctions; poor law enforcement with excessive punitive measures; power imbalances in the value chain and illegal timber harvesting; the lack of a multiple forest-use framework; and overlapping, conflictual customary and regulatory governance. This paper argues that at present, the long-term sustainability of the Brazil nut concession system seems compromised. If the Brazil nut concession system is to enter into a new decade, this may only be possible by formally recognizing the multiplicity of land uses, implementing and validating sound silvicultural approaches, minimizing land use and management trade-offs in alignment with local aspirations, and establishing effective negotiation platforms with different productive sectors and government agencies.

LanguageEnglish
Pages254-265
Number of pages12
JournalInternational Forestry Review
Volume21
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2019

Fingerprint

Brazil nuts
nut
concession
Brazil
governance
land use
conservation areas
Bertholletia excelsa
multiple use forestry
protected area
law enforcement
government agencies
poor law
forest canopy
supply chain
information sources
timber harvesting
land management
sanction
Peru

Keywords

  • forest concessions
  • forest governance
  • non-timber forest products
  • smallholder forestry
  • value chains

Cite this

@article{f00c190e19c04b2990fe3e89fd68652a,
title = "Brazil Nut Forest Concessions in the Peruvian Amazon: Success or Failure?",
abstract = "In Peru, concessions for harvesting Brazil nuts (fruits of the Amazon tree Bertholletia excelsa) were launched in the Madre de Dios Department in 2000. This study analyses the extent to which the Brazil nut concession system (which covers about 1 million ha of closed canopy forest) has met its objective of providing a governance model for sustainable and equitable use. Primary and secondary information sources were used to analyse governance outcomes based on 10 indicators, and the performance of Brazil nut concessions in two contrasting land-use types in Madre de Dios were compared (within and outside protected areas). It was found that corresponding institutional arrangements have led, more than a decade later, to different socioeconomic, ecological and legal outcomes. Particularly outside protected areas, where the vast majority of the concessions are located, a paradoxical situation was found of ineffective over-regulation on paper but minimal intervention from state agencies; ineffective state monitoring and sanctions; poor law enforcement with excessive punitive measures; power imbalances in the value chain and illegal timber harvesting; the lack of a multiple forest-use framework; and overlapping, conflictual customary and regulatory governance. This paper argues that at present, the long-term sustainability of the Brazil nut concession system seems compromised. If the Brazil nut concession system is to enter into a new decade, this may only be possible by formally recognizing the multiplicity of land uses, implementing and validating sound silvicultural approaches, minimizing land use and management trade-offs in alignment with local aspirations, and establishing effective negotiation platforms with different productive sectors and government agencies.",
keywords = "forest concessions, forest governance, non-timber forest products, smallholder forestry, value chains",
author = "H.V. Willem and V.J. Ingram and M.R. Guariguata",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1505/146554819826606540",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "254--265",
journal = "International Forestry Review",
issn = "1465-5489",
publisher = "Commonwealth Forestry Association",
number = "2",

}

Brazil Nut Forest Concessions in the Peruvian Amazon: Success or Failure? / Willem, H.V.; Ingram, V.J.; Guariguata, M.R.

In: International Forestry Review, Vol. 21, No. 2, 01.05.2019, p. 254-265.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Brazil Nut Forest Concessions in the Peruvian Amazon: Success or Failure?

AU - Willem, H.V.

AU - Ingram, V.J.

AU - Guariguata, M.R.

PY - 2019/5/1

Y1 - 2019/5/1

N2 - In Peru, concessions for harvesting Brazil nuts (fruits of the Amazon tree Bertholletia excelsa) were launched in the Madre de Dios Department in 2000. This study analyses the extent to which the Brazil nut concession system (which covers about 1 million ha of closed canopy forest) has met its objective of providing a governance model for sustainable and equitable use. Primary and secondary information sources were used to analyse governance outcomes based on 10 indicators, and the performance of Brazil nut concessions in two contrasting land-use types in Madre de Dios were compared (within and outside protected areas). It was found that corresponding institutional arrangements have led, more than a decade later, to different socioeconomic, ecological and legal outcomes. Particularly outside protected areas, where the vast majority of the concessions are located, a paradoxical situation was found of ineffective over-regulation on paper but minimal intervention from state agencies; ineffective state monitoring and sanctions; poor law enforcement with excessive punitive measures; power imbalances in the value chain and illegal timber harvesting; the lack of a multiple forest-use framework; and overlapping, conflictual customary and regulatory governance. This paper argues that at present, the long-term sustainability of the Brazil nut concession system seems compromised. If the Brazil nut concession system is to enter into a new decade, this may only be possible by formally recognizing the multiplicity of land uses, implementing and validating sound silvicultural approaches, minimizing land use and management trade-offs in alignment with local aspirations, and establishing effective negotiation platforms with different productive sectors and government agencies.

AB - In Peru, concessions for harvesting Brazil nuts (fruits of the Amazon tree Bertholletia excelsa) were launched in the Madre de Dios Department in 2000. This study analyses the extent to which the Brazil nut concession system (which covers about 1 million ha of closed canopy forest) has met its objective of providing a governance model for sustainable and equitable use. Primary and secondary information sources were used to analyse governance outcomes based on 10 indicators, and the performance of Brazil nut concessions in two contrasting land-use types in Madre de Dios were compared (within and outside protected areas). It was found that corresponding institutional arrangements have led, more than a decade later, to different socioeconomic, ecological and legal outcomes. Particularly outside protected areas, where the vast majority of the concessions are located, a paradoxical situation was found of ineffective over-regulation on paper but minimal intervention from state agencies; ineffective state monitoring and sanctions; poor law enforcement with excessive punitive measures; power imbalances in the value chain and illegal timber harvesting; the lack of a multiple forest-use framework; and overlapping, conflictual customary and regulatory governance. This paper argues that at present, the long-term sustainability of the Brazil nut concession system seems compromised. If the Brazil nut concession system is to enter into a new decade, this may only be possible by formally recognizing the multiplicity of land uses, implementing and validating sound silvicultural approaches, minimizing land use and management trade-offs in alignment with local aspirations, and establishing effective negotiation platforms with different productive sectors and government agencies.

KW - forest concessions

KW - forest governance

KW - non-timber forest products

KW - smallholder forestry

KW - value chains

U2 - 10.1505/146554819826606540

DO - 10.1505/146554819826606540

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 254

EP - 265

JO - International Forestry Review

T2 - International Forestry Review

JF - International Forestry Review

SN - 1465-5489

IS - 2

ER -