Barbarie o justicia en la Patagonia occidental

Las violencias coloniales en el ocaso del pueblo kawésqar, finales del siglo XIX e inicios del siglo XX

Translated title of the contribution: Barbarism or justice in western patagonia: Forms of colonial violence during the twilight of the kawésqar people, at the end of the 19th and start of the 20th centuries

Alberto Harambour*, José Barrena Ruiz

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Objective/context: This article analyzes the particular forms of inter-ethnic violence in the territory of the coastal or inter-coastal waters (territorio marino o maritorio) of the lands historically occupied by the Kawésqar indigenous group. Originality: In contrast with the widespread notion that the extinction of the Kawésqar nation took place without the interference of the State and essentially resulted from European diseases, this article holds that the particular forms of violence used against them were systematic and long-lasting, and encouraged by the racism of the State itself. The term maritorio, referring to the maritime frontiers of a nation, is taken from architecture and enables us to understand the radical difference between the Kawésqar socio-ecological system and the ways in which the Chilean State constructed a sovereignty, delegated and direct, in a transitional scenario. Methodology: The bulk of this investigation draws on judicial archives, which were not previously consulted, in order to analyze inter-ethnic conflicts during the start of the Western colonization of Patagonia. Since the victims of the appropriation of those indigenous territories by the State and business interests rarely figure in these proceedings, a micro-historical analysis was made of the public and private narratives about the denial of humanity to the canoeros. Conclusions: This study concludes that the violence practiced against the indigenous people of the western channels was systematic and constant, and that its use was endorsed by the colonialism of the Chilean State.
Original languageSpanish
Pages (from-to)25-48
JournalHistoria Critica
Volume2019
Issue number71
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2019

Fingerprint

barbarism
twilight
violence
justice
ethnic conflict
racism
colonialism
ecological system
sovereignty
historical analysis
colonial age
colonization
coastal water
interference
extinction
scenario
Disease
narrative
water
methodology

Cite this

@article{adcc239485884d7fa5038809eeca2a3f,
title = "Barbarie o justicia en la Patagonia occidental: Las violencias coloniales en el ocaso del pueblo kaw{\'e}sqar, finales del siglo XIX e inicios del siglo XX",
abstract = "Objective/context: This article analyzes the particular forms of inter-ethnic violence in the territory of the coastal or inter-coastal waters (territorio marino o maritorio) of the lands historically occupied by the Kaw{\'e}sqar indigenous group. Originality: In contrast with the widespread notion that the extinction of the Kaw{\'e}sqar nation took place without the interference of the State and essentially resulted from European diseases, this article holds that the particular forms of violence used against them were systematic and long-lasting, and encouraged by the racism of the State itself. The term maritorio, referring to the maritime frontiers of a nation, is taken from architecture and enables us to understand the radical difference between the Kaw{\'e}sqar socio-ecological system and the ways in which the Chilean State constructed a sovereignty, delegated and direct, in a transitional scenario. Methodology: The bulk of this investigation draws on judicial archives, which were not previously consulted, in order to analyze inter-ethnic conflicts during the start of the Western colonization of Patagonia. Since the victims of the appropriation of those indigenous territories by the State and business interests rarely figure in these proceedings, a micro-historical analysis was made of the public and private narratives about the denial of humanity to the canoeros. Conclusions: This study concludes that the violence practiced against the indigenous people of the western channels was systematic and constant, and that its use was endorsed by the colonialism of the Chilean State.",
author = "Alberto Harambour and Ruiz, {Jos{\'e} Barrena}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.7440/histcrit71.2019.02",
language = "Spanish",
volume = "2019",
pages = "25--48",
journal = "Historia Critica",
issn = "0121-1617",
publisher = "Universidad de los Andes",
number = "71",

}

Barbarie o justicia en la Patagonia occidental : Las violencias coloniales en el ocaso del pueblo kawésqar, finales del siglo XIX e inicios del siglo XX. / Harambour, Alberto; Ruiz, José Barrena.

In: Historia Critica, Vol. 2019, No. 71, 01.01.2019, p. 25-48.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Barbarie o justicia en la Patagonia occidental

T2 - Las violencias coloniales en el ocaso del pueblo kawésqar, finales del siglo XIX e inicios del siglo XX

AU - Harambour, Alberto

AU - Ruiz, José Barrena

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Objective/context: This article analyzes the particular forms of inter-ethnic violence in the territory of the coastal or inter-coastal waters (territorio marino o maritorio) of the lands historically occupied by the Kawésqar indigenous group. Originality: In contrast with the widespread notion that the extinction of the Kawésqar nation took place without the interference of the State and essentially resulted from European diseases, this article holds that the particular forms of violence used against them were systematic and long-lasting, and encouraged by the racism of the State itself. The term maritorio, referring to the maritime frontiers of a nation, is taken from architecture and enables us to understand the radical difference between the Kawésqar socio-ecological system and the ways in which the Chilean State constructed a sovereignty, delegated and direct, in a transitional scenario. Methodology: The bulk of this investigation draws on judicial archives, which were not previously consulted, in order to analyze inter-ethnic conflicts during the start of the Western colonization of Patagonia. Since the victims of the appropriation of those indigenous territories by the State and business interests rarely figure in these proceedings, a micro-historical analysis was made of the public and private narratives about the denial of humanity to the canoeros. Conclusions: This study concludes that the violence practiced against the indigenous people of the western channels was systematic and constant, and that its use was endorsed by the colonialism of the Chilean State.

AB - Objective/context: This article analyzes the particular forms of inter-ethnic violence in the territory of the coastal or inter-coastal waters (territorio marino o maritorio) of the lands historically occupied by the Kawésqar indigenous group. Originality: In contrast with the widespread notion that the extinction of the Kawésqar nation took place without the interference of the State and essentially resulted from European diseases, this article holds that the particular forms of violence used against them were systematic and long-lasting, and encouraged by the racism of the State itself. The term maritorio, referring to the maritime frontiers of a nation, is taken from architecture and enables us to understand the radical difference between the Kawésqar socio-ecological system and the ways in which the Chilean State constructed a sovereignty, delegated and direct, in a transitional scenario. Methodology: The bulk of this investigation draws on judicial archives, which were not previously consulted, in order to analyze inter-ethnic conflicts during the start of the Western colonization of Patagonia. Since the victims of the appropriation of those indigenous territories by the State and business interests rarely figure in these proceedings, a micro-historical analysis was made of the public and private narratives about the denial of humanity to the canoeros. Conclusions: This study concludes that the violence practiced against the indigenous people of the western channels was systematic and constant, and that its use was endorsed by the colonialism of the Chilean State.

U2 - 10.7440/histcrit71.2019.02

DO - 10.7440/histcrit71.2019.02

M3 - Article

VL - 2019

SP - 25

EP - 48

JO - Historia Critica

JF - Historia Critica

SN - 0121-1617

IS - 71

ER -